Legal Cyber Academy
All insights

Webinar Recap: Turning Blockchain Records Into Admissible Evidence

By the Legal Cyber Academy editorial team ·

Free courses on this

Recorded lectures, free to watch, no account needed.

Browse all free courses

Crypto is no longer confined to headline prosecutions. Digital assets now surface in divorces, estates and routine commercial fights, and many of the lawyers handling those matters have no forensic team behind them. The difficulty is that a blockchain record, however permanent, does not prove itself in court.

That gap was the subject of From Blockchain to Courtroom: Preserving and Proving Digital Asset Evidence, a Legal Cyber Academy webinar moderated by Daniel B. Garrie, founder of Law & Forensics and a JAMS neutral. He was joined by Hon. Jackson Lucky, a retired California state court judge and JAMS neutral; Justin Herring, a Mayer Brown partner and former federal cybercrime prosecutor; and Angus F. Ni, a partner at Morrow Ni LLP.

Permanent Does Not Mean Accurate

The panel separated two ideas that tribunals often merge. An entry that cannot be altered tells a fact-finder nothing about whether it was right when recorded, or who caused it. Panelists also pushed back on the belief that every coin can be followed: mixers, decentralized exchanges and wrapped tokens can break the trail, and real tracing takes far longer than many clients expect.

Machine-Generated Data Is an Authentication Issue

On admissibility, the panel's view was that a public ledger is machine-generated, so hearsay and the business records exception are usually the wrong frame. The work falls under Federal Rules of Evidence 901 and 902. The examples in Rule 901 are non-exclusive, and the standard asks only whether enough evidence exists for a fact-finder to conclude the item is what its proponent claims. Because a decentralized ledger has no custodian to subpoena, proponents have generally relied on an expert to describe what the chain shows.

Two technical cautions came with that. A matching hash confirms only that a copy matches its source, not that the source is genuine. And the time recorded on a chain may need expert explanation before it can be lined up with events in the physical world.

Attribution Is Where Cases Turn

The ledger records addresses and amounts but names no one. Panelists treated attribution as the decisive step, and much of that proof is conventional: messages claiming ownership, spending for a person's benefit, funds mixed with known accounts, and off-chain bank and card records.

Commercial tracing tools add clustering, which infers common control of addresses from transaction patterns, IP data and proprietary sources. The panel urged that expert reports keep those inferences distinct from ledger facts. An expert who blurs the two risks credibility, and opponents should not assume a Daubert challenge will exclude the testimony.

Discovery Protocols and Lost Keys

A standard ESI protocol, in the panel's view, needs revision for a blockchain dispute, because a single set of transactions can involve full-node data, block explorers, exchange records, wallet images and smart contract state. Self-custody adds another hazard. A private key that is memorized, destroyed or lost with its owner can put assets beyond recovery, and deliberate destruction may never be provable.

Weighing Arbitration

Arbitration offers confidentiality and, in some states, attachment orders when a case begins. The trade-off is that most seats provide no subpoena power over nonparty exchanges, though panelists pointed to the California Arbitration Act as one route to third-party discovery.

The full free course covers each of these points in more depth, including the ledger types and the ESI checklist the panel reviewed.

Watch the full webinar course

This article draws on the Legal Cyber Academy course From Blockchain to Courtroom: Preserving and Proving Digital Asset Evidence with Daniel B. Garrie, Justin Herring, Hon. Jackson Lucky and Angus F. Ni. The course is free and includes the full recording, the slides, study notes and a final exam with a certificate of completion.

Go deeper — courses on this

Keep reading

Get the next one by email

Plain-English analysis of the law-and-technology developments that change how you advise. No more than monthly, and you can leave whenever you like.