Legal Cyber Academy

HIPAA Overview and Covered Entities

Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.

Up next

HIPAA Privacy Rule: Protected Information and Permitted Disclosures
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.

00:23:04HIPAA, I'll just quickly run through these slides

00:23:06just because they're not so exciting.

00:23:08HIPAA came about in 1996, really,

00:23:12and they had to do with the fact

00:23:13that some congressmen said,

00:23:14I'm not gonna pontificate here.

00:23:16But anyways, the point is,

00:23:17is that people wanted

00:23:18their private healthcare information protected.

00:23:21They passed this law called HIPAA.

00:23:23They published this new law on top of that

00:23:26called Privacy Rule Health and Human Services,

00:23:29published the actual regulation in 2002.

00:23:32You know, that's lightning speed,

00:23:33six years in government time

00:23:35to actually get something,

00:23:36to then make everybody do a bunch of work.

00:23:38But anyways, the point is,

00:23:40is that they did get there,

00:23:41and the important part, the key takeaways,

00:23:44is they created this thing called,

00:23:45well, they created it,

00:23:46but they leveraged this concept

00:23:47of personal identifiable information

00:23:49and personal healthcare information, right?

00:23:51And they created this idea of a national standard,

00:23:54like this, you know,

00:23:55we in the United States,

00:23:56when I teach this class at Harvard,

00:23:57where I say,

00:23:58we're not the most operationally,

00:24:01legislatively smart organization.

00:24:03We've taken this, like, total porridge, right?

00:24:05We've said, healthcare, you're different

00:24:07than everybody else.

00:24:08We're gonna have privacy rule, you know?

00:24:10We've created this really interesting,

00:24:12dynamic, multi-layered system that,

00:24:14for whatever reason,

00:24:15still hasn't strangled everything to death.

00:24:18And what it functionally does

00:24:20is they created a national standard, right,

00:24:23to protect sensitive patient health information.

00:24:26That's the goal of HIPAA, you know?

00:24:28And who's covered by HIPAA?

00:24:30You know, I'll let, you know,

00:24:32Jennifer and then Azul and Dave

00:24:34sort of weigh in here as to who's actually covered.

00:24:37But the whole idea is that we have

00:24:39health information,

00:24:41and there's a national statute that basically says,

00:24:44you need to be aware that this information

00:24:46needs to be protected at some minimum standard or a floor.

00:24:49And then that's where they kind of,

00:24:52like, what we'll say there,

00:24:54but maybe you guys can weigh in quickly,

00:24:56is covered entities, right?

00:24:58This is something lawyers really struggle with.

00:25:00And this is, especially with third-party

00:25:02and fourth-party risk,

00:25:03this is where it gets really,

00:25:05they're like, am I really a covered entity,

00:25:07even though I didn't fill out

00:25:08a business associate agreement?

00:25:09I'm like, I don't know,

00:25:10you had all the patient information?

00:25:12I go, I don't know what we call that.

00:25:14But, you know, that's me in the mediation,

00:25:16you know, trying to bring a dose of reality

00:25:18to what actually happens in a courtroom

00:25:21and in a trial, you know,

00:25:23because I don't think grandma cares

00:25:25that you used a third-party or fourth-party.

00:25:27She cares the fact either all of her cancer treatment

00:25:30is now sitting on the dark web,

00:25:32and it's because your auditor's auditor

00:25:34was using a third-party transfer tool.

00:25:36You know, well, they're not a business associate.

00:25:38But maybe, you know, Jennifer and Azul and Dave,

00:25:41you can sort of weigh in here.

00:25:42What is a covered entity,

00:25:43and how does that actually functionally work, right?

00:25:45Everybody, we can all read the world,

00:25:47but functionally, what's that look like?

00:25:49Yeah, so you've got covered entity

00:25:52and business associate status under HIPAA,

00:25:54and the starting point is,

00:25:55what are you doing with protected health information?

00:25:58You're going to be looking at how you're collecting it,

00:26:00how you're receiving it,

00:26:01what are you using it for?

00:26:02But there's different requirements and standards

00:26:05for a covered entity

00:26:06compared to a business associate throughout HIPAA.

00:26:09Simple, health insurance company,

00:26:11their covered entity,

00:26:12going to your primary care physician,

00:26:14their covered entity.

00:26:15But say your primary care physician

00:26:18is utilizing a different service for billing.

00:26:22The billing of their services

00:26:23is run through a different organization.

00:26:25So the PHI is flowing from my primary care physician

00:26:27over to this other organization

00:26:29that is utilizing it to provide a service

00:26:31to the covered entity,

00:26:32which is Bill Jen for that treatment

00:26:34that she received over at the covered entity.

00:26:36So the firm that's using it for billing purposes,

00:26:41they're not collecting it from me,

00:26:42they're collecting it from the covered entity,

00:26:44primary care physician,

00:26:45but they're utilizing it to seek money from me

00:26:47that they're then going to pay back over

00:26:49to the primary care physician.

00:26:51So in that hypothetical,

00:26:52you've got the primary care physician

00:26:53as the covered entity

00:26:54and the billing organization as the business associate.

00:26:58But Daniel, you tongue in cheek said,

00:27:00am I really the covered entity?

00:27:02We go through this question with our clients all the time.

00:27:05So of the 1800 organizations, healthcare organizations

00:27:09that we counseled over the past few years,

00:27:11there are real discussions happening with,

00:27:14are you truly the covered entity

00:27:16or are you the business associate here?

00:27:18Or are you truly the business associate

00:27:20or are you the covered entity here?

00:27:22Or are you neither a covered entity

00:27:24nor a business associate,

00:27:26but you executed a document

00:27:28that has business associate agreement on top.

00:27:30And what does that mean for your organization?

00:27:33It's the same thing that I hear too all the time.

00:27:38When we have these kinds of discussions

00:27:40with any kind of incidences,

00:27:42that's the first question.

00:27:43Well, were we the covered entity in this situation

00:27:45or the business associate or either?

00:27:48Honestly, I think this is part of HIPAA law

00:27:51that I think needs to be rewritten

00:27:52and clarified a little bit better,

00:27:54so it's not questionable.

00:27:55And maybe, Daniel,

00:27:57this is one of the things

00:27:58that we should be doing with the new AI.

00:28:00Let the AI rewrite HIPAA law.

00:28:03I would love to see what the NDPC

00:28:06spits out in response to that ask.

00:28:11That's probably not a bad idea.

00:28:13Ozil, your thoughts here?

00:28:15I'm sure.

00:28:16So that's definitely always a discussion.

00:28:19For my advantage point,

00:28:22the healthcare organization

00:28:25that's under my company,

00:28:29so my company name is Apo Health

00:28:31and the healthcare organization

00:28:32that sits under Apo Health.

00:28:34Apo Health is a biotech pharmaceutical.

00:28:35It's not covered entity.

00:28:37It could be business-associated

00:28:38if it goes to business with another healthcare.

00:28:41But bioreference laboratory itself

00:28:44is a covered entity

00:28:45as it processes healthcare information

00:28:48for the patients.

00:28:49And then we do get into those discussions

00:28:53when we seek assistance

00:28:57from our business partners

00:29:00vis-a-vis the vendors

00:29:02and the providers and so forth.

00:29:04Of course, I have to draw expertise

00:29:08from my legal and compliance teams

00:29:10as far as defining the business associates.

00:29:13But we do, from IT perspective,

00:29:16what we do have to make sure is

00:29:19we're going through all the compliance

00:29:22and the regulatory requirements checkpoints

00:29:25and making sure, is it a covered entity?

00:29:29Is it a business associate?

00:29:31Is it going to access PHI?

00:29:34Do we need a business associate agreement?

00:29:37And how do we execute that

00:29:39and then go through our legal

00:29:40and compliance department

00:29:41to go through those processes?

00:29:43So this is the most interesting question

00:29:45that I've been confronting, right,

00:29:47is the reality that you run your IT shop,

00:29:50they go to the billing department,

00:29:52you have a contract that says,

00:29:54I'm going to comply with HIPAA, blah, blah, blah.

00:29:57Here's a covered entity,

00:29:58health plans definition,

00:29:59clearing houses here,

00:30:01providers here,

00:30:02and then you get business associates here.

00:30:06So then we go through,

00:30:07we take Jen's example,

00:30:08and I use the billing company.

00:30:10The billing company's agreed

00:30:11to be HIPAA compliant.

00:30:12The billing company then uses

00:30:14some third-party software application

00:30:16in its technology stack

00:30:18to transfer data back and forth

00:30:20and then all of a sudden,

00:30:23the technology company that's being used

00:30:25to manage the transfer

00:30:27of the billing information

00:30:28is compromised.

00:30:29So not the business associate.

00:30:31Business associate isn't compromised itself.

00:30:34It's a technology company, right?

00:30:36This is where it gets interesting.

00:30:37Technology company says,

00:30:38oh, I don't need to tell

00:30:39the business associate

00:30:40because I don't know

00:30:41if their information was impacted.

00:30:42Then they fast forward

00:30:43because you know how it works

00:30:44in an incident.

00:30:45Nothing is what it seems.

00:30:47Everything changes.

00:30:48Three weeks later, they're like,

00:30:50oh, their data was taken too.

00:30:52So then they notify

00:30:54the business associate

00:30:55that it looks like

00:30:56your information was taken.

00:30:58Then that business associate

00:30:59then notifies the covered entity.

00:31:01Now the question,

00:31:02the question that I see playing out

00:31:04is who tells who what, right?

00:31:07Because you don't have any of it.

00:31:09You as a covered entity

00:31:10have no idea about that incident, right?

00:31:13You are twice removed at best

00:31:16from that technology company, right?

00:31:18So what are you going to do?

00:31:19You're going to call the technology company

00:31:20and say, my vendor's vendor

00:31:21used your technology stack.

00:31:23You need to tell us

00:31:24because my lawyers are asking me

00:31:26what's going on, right?

00:31:27And this again emphasizes

00:31:29the importance of having an audit

00:31:31and having all of your agreements

00:31:32look like.

00:31:33If your agreements are executed

00:31:34properly, then theoretically

00:31:36you'll have some authority

00:31:37to ask for that information.

00:31:38But who tells me what?

00:31:40Like legitimately,

00:31:41like how does that information,

00:31:43because at the end of the day,

00:31:44who tells grandma

00:31:45that her cancer records,

00:31:47because the billing company

00:31:49was using this with all the,

00:31:51you know, Medicare,

00:31:53the OCT, anyways,

00:31:54these codes are all now on the web

00:31:56and then for sale,

00:31:57like how does that eventually get

00:31:58to what the statute was intending,

00:32:00which is to protect

00:32:01the healthcare information

00:32:02of the consumer

00:32:03and make them aware of that, right?

00:32:05That to me is the complicated question,

00:32:08right?

00:32:09And how does that work?

00:32:10And I, you got,

00:32:11and I tell, you know,

00:32:12the security people like,

00:32:13look, we're securing it,

00:32:14but we can write the contracts

00:32:15and you're not wrong.

00:32:16Like I agree with you wholeheartedly,

00:32:18right?

00:32:19I mean, it's a conversation,

00:32:20but how does that work,

00:32:21Jennifer, at a practical level?

00:32:23And then also,

00:32:24how does it work to vet

00:32:25the IT technology stack, right?

00:32:27How do you even vet that, right?

00:32:30How do you know

00:32:31the business associates

00:32:32using this technology?

00:32:33What is some strategies

00:32:35you would tell lawyers

00:32:36that this is the authority

00:32:37we need to have

00:32:38so we could do our job

00:32:40more effectively

00:32:41and answer the questions

00:32:42you're asking us, right?

00:32:43Because they're asking you questions

00:32:45like we don't know.

00:32:46So what do you,

00:32:47what authority or information

00:32:48do you need?

00:32:49So maybe Jennifer,

00:32:50Dave, you guys can weigh in here.

00:32:53Yeah, so this highlights

00:32:54the importance of two things.

00:32:55One, a vendor management program

00:32:57and two, ensuring appropriate contracts

00:32:59are in place between organizations.

00:33:01So in this hypothetical,

00:33:03a good vendor management program

00:33:06would reveal the covered entity

00:33:09is speaking with the business associate

00:33:11and understanding what the business associate

00:33:13has in place regarding

00:33:14their own security,

00:33:15but also what vendors

00:33:16are they utilizing

00:33:17that may be involved

00:33:18in the ecosystem

00:33:19of their information sharing

00:33:20and then making sure we're vetting

00:33:22with those vendors.

00:33:24Are they good vendors

00:33:25or is it mom and pops IT shop

00:33:27and somebody that we don't want

00:33:28having our information?

00:33:29So the vendor management program

00:33:31should help identify

00:33:33who's involved

00:33:34in this entire chain.

00:33:36The contract

00:33:37is then going to specify

00:33:39how people communicate

00:33:41with each other,

00:33:42when, how,

00:33:43and what is going to be communicated

00:33:45so that in this scenario,

00:33:47assuming there's a great

00:33:48vendor management program,

00:33:50the contract between the sub BAA

00:33:52and the business associate

00:33:53should require certain reporting

00:33:55within a very narrow window of time

00:33:57so that the BAA can then report

00:33:58up to the covered entity.

00:33:59But you can also build in there

00:34:01that the sub business associate

00:34:02is going to cooperate

00:34:04with any and all investigation

00:34:06into a data privacy incident

00:34:07regarding the security

00:34:08of their systems

00:34:09or information that was stored

00:34:10on their systems.

00:34:11Cooperation may include

00:34:13but is not limited to

00:34:14communications and conversations

00:34:16and information sharing

00:34:17with the business associate

00:34:18and with the covered entity.

00:34:19Because the covered entity

00:34:20is going to have the requirement

00:34:22under HIPAA

00:34:23to perform the notifications

00:34:24that are required

00:34:25to individuals,

00:34:26to regulators,

00:34:27to media,

00:34:28to other third parties.

00:34:29But they're going to need information

00:34:31ultimately from the sub business associate

00:34:33in order to fulfill those obligations.

00:34:35But taking the contract piece

00:34:37a step further,

00:34:38they also have the ability

00:34:39to negotiate that notification

00:34:41to be done by the business associate.

00:34:43But a covered entity

00:34:44never wants to say

00:34:45in a contract business associate

00:34:46you will fulfill

00:34:47the notification obligations, period.

00:34:49Because the covered entity

00:34:50is still responsible

00:34:51for ensuring that

00:34:52the content requirements

00:34:54are met in the notification.

00:34:55That the deadline is met

00:34:56in the notification going out.

00:34:58That the right parties

00:34:59are being notified.

00:35:00And they're going to be subject

00:35:01to an investigation as well.

00:35:03And that's really important.

00:35:05Yeah, they can absolutely

00:35:07be brought back into

00:35:08ensuring there was compliance

00:35:10with the breach notification rule.

00:35:12Even though the notifications

00:35:13were done by another party.

00:35:14But the investigation launched

00:35:16by OCR isn't just going to focus

00:35:18on the breach notification rule.

00:35:20They also want to talk

00:35:21about the security rule.

00:35:22They also want to talk

00:35:23about the privacy rule.

00:35:24So all roads lead back to HIPAA

00:35:26and not just narrow compliance

00:35:28with a limited part of HIPAA.

00:35:29It's going to be broad compliance

00:35:31investigations that occur.

00:35:33And then that investigation

00:35:34will then be used

00:35:35against the board

00:35:36for not having appropriate oversight

00:35:38if they don't.

00:35:39Exactly.

00:35:40And that's where this whole thing

00:35:43all kind of gets wrapped up

00:35:45in a nice bundle of confusing,

00:35:47complicated, profitable,

00:35:50legal technology.

00:35:51Me, for free.

00:35:52No, I'm kidding.

00:35:53But it becomes quite a bit more

00:35:55complex.

00:35:56But it becomes a lot more

00:35:57complicated.

00:35:58Up until recently, it wasn't,

00:36:00you know, up until recently,

00:36:01HHS and OCR had their lane.

00:36:04The SEC had their lane.

00:36:06Right?

00:36:07Everybody had a lane.

00:36:08Right?

00:36:09And now we're seeing this

00:36:10coalescing of all of it.

00:36:11Right?

00:36:12I'd love to hear, you know,

00:36:13Ava, what is the information?

00:36:14What would you like lawyers to know?

00:36:16This is what we need to get

00:36:18in order to answer whether or not,

00:36:21like, what is the specific things

00:36:23that you feel that lawyers

00:36:24could learn to be asking for?

00:36:27Right?

00:36:28Because they don't have a chance

00:36:29often to talk to people

00:36:30in your and Dave's level of caliber

00:36:32to say, hey, guys,

00:36:34if you put this in

00:36:35and get us this information,

00:36:36I can answer your question

00:36:37in 24 hours and not a week.

00:36:39Right?

00:36:40What do you need to know?

00:36:41So maybe you guys,

00:36:42Ava and Dave,

00:36:43you can share your thoughts

00:36:44and then we'll keep it going.

00:36:46Sure.

00:36:47So when I,

00:36:51so I can humbly brag

00:36:54that we do have a good vendor

00:36:55management program

00:36:57here in the company.

00:36:59And we are very lucky with

00:37:02and fortunate to have the lawyers

00:37:06that we have in our compliance

00:37:08and in our legal department.

00:37:09So I would work with them

00:37:13in this case,

00:37:15what Jennifer just mentioned

00:37:17to do all of those things.

00:37:18And so I am the third leg

00:37:24of a contracting process.

00:37:27So when the contracts

00:37:28are being reviewed,

00:37:29whether it's a vendor contract

00:37:31or even it's any contract

00:37:33for that matter,

00:37:34they are reviewed by compliance,

00:37:36they are reviewed by legal compliance

00:37:38as well as security.

00:37:41But do you like,

00:37:42do you encourage them

00:37:43to give you an application list

00:37:44that they're using?

00:37:45Of course, like what,

00:37:47because like what information

00:37:48from the security side of the house,

00:37:50do you want to make sure

00:37:51you get access to for a business associate

00:37:54because I can tell you

00:37:55as the mediator,

00:37:56as the person who gets involved

00:37:58in these, right?

00:37:59The contracts are amorphous at best.

00:38:02They, as Jennifer pointed out,

00:38:04sometimes just have the word

00:38:05business associated in them.

00:38:06And that, you know,

00:38:08is its own ensuing problem.

00:38:09So I'd love to hear

00:38:10from you and Dave, like,

00:38:11do you want a list

00:38:12of key core applications?

00:38:14Do you want them?

00:38:15How does that work, right?

00:38:16Because you guys work in technology.

00:38:18Nobody knows everything people use,

00:38:20right?

00:38:21I mean, it's just a, you know,

00:38:23it doesn't happen.

00:38:25Ideally, we want all of them.

00:38:27We want to see everything

00:38:29of our service provider,

00:38:31whether it's business

00:38:32associated with these,

00:38:33a third party or fourth party, right?

00:38:35But it's always subject

00:38:36to the resources.

00:38:37It's always subject

00:38:38to what they want to show us, right?

00:38:41The vendors, they're not necessarily,

00:38:43they would want to share

00:38:44everything that they have.

00:38:45So the way that we go by is

00:38:47we use a Q&A process,

00:38:52a questionnaire process.

00:38:54We use any attestation services

00:38:57that they have,

00:38:58whether it's a SOC tool report,

00:39:00whether it's an ISO report.

00:39:01We rely on those things

00:39:03because they are being performed

00:39:04by third parties at the vendor,

00:39:06for the vendor environment.

00:39:08So we rely on them.

00:39:10We advise,

00:39:12I advise our legal counsel

00:39:14and compliance department

00:39:16to ask for those information for us

00:39:18so that we can review them

00:39:20and see what kind of security

00:39:23and risk management practices

00:39:25they have in that environment.

00:39:27And of course,

00:39:28they extend that information

00:39:30to your point,

00:39:32fourth party and fifth party,

00:39:34because who asks what?

00:39:36For the purpose of that,

00:39:37it's always,

00:39:38we go to our immediate vendor

00:39:40and they are obligated

00:39:41through the contractual,

00:39:42although the contracts are probably

00:39:44as fast as you just mentioned,

00:39:45but nonetheless,

00:39:46it is a tool,

00:39:48one of the tool in the

00:39:50entrepreneurship.

00:39:51No, that's a great point.

00:39:52No, I mean,

00:39:53lawyers should take heat.

00:39:54You should make sure

00:39:55that there's a clause in there

00:39:56that says,

00:39:57hey, look,

00:39:58we want you to be able

00:39:59to provide us access

00:40:00to your third party technology

00:40:02tools that we're using

00:40:04so that we can get appropriate

00:40:05technical information

00:40:06to make an evaluation.

00:40:08Like, let me tell you something,

00:40:09if that's not in the contract,

00:40:10nobody's going to go out of their way

00:40:12to do that for you because if they,

00:40:14and it's just a reality, right?

00:40:16That technology provider

00:40:18probably has 500 or 1,000

00:40:20or thousands of people

00:40:21that have been hit and impacted

00:40:22and you are one of the many.

00:40:24Unless it's your brother-in-law,

00:40:25your family,

00:40:26or you're like one of

00:40:27their biggest customers,

00:40:28there's just the reality is

00:40:29is that if you don't have it

00:40:30in a contract,

00:40:31they're not going to be like,

00:40:32okay, we're going to get that

00:40:33to you, right?

00:40:34You have no real rights.

00:40:35So that's an excellent point.

00:40:36I don't know, David,

00:40:37anything you want to add to that

00:40:38for lawyers to keep?

00:40:39Yeah, this is a great

00:40:40conversation, Daniel.

00:40:41This is what I've always

00:40:42appreciated about your webinars

00:40:43is you're trying to get

00:40:44that hook in there

00:40:45and what should the attorneys

00:40:46be asking of their security folks

00:40:48and privacy folks.

00:40:49And quite frankly,

00:40:50that goes the other way too

00:40:51because we need to know

00:40:53what you need to represent

00:40:56my organization,

00:40:57for instance,

00:40:58if I'm CSO to ABC Healthcare

00:41:01and I'm trying to build a program,

00:41:03I need to be coming to you

00:41:04to ask you what do you need

00:41:06for me to ensure

00:41:07what I'm putting in place

00:41:09you can properly defend

00:41:11if something happens.

00:41:12That's a great point for lawyers.

00:41:14What I'm asking for,

00:41:16what I would say is

00:41:19for the attorneys out there,

00:41:21I would ask that you ask

00:41:24that there is an open line

00:41:26of communications

00:41:27and regular touch points

00:41:28with the security lead

00:41:30to understand what's going on

00:41:32and for that security lead

00:41:34to be providing back

00:41:35to the legal teams

00:41:37what they're currently facing

00:41:39in threats and risks

00:41:41and where the weaknesses are

00:41:42because that's what's going

00:41:43to get attacked

00:41:44if there's ever any kind

00:41:46of a legal thing going on.

00:41:48So I kind of like the idea

00:41:50and this is what I always

00:41:52try to do.

00:41:53One of the first people

00:41:54I always meet

00:41:55when I go into a new org

00:41:56is usually the legal team

00:41:57because I ask those kinds

00:41:59of questions,

00:42:00what do you need for me

00:42:01in case something happens?

00:42:02What do you want to know

00:42:03and keep that communications open

00:42:05and then I go obviously

00:42:07over to the compliance department

00:42:08and start learning,

00:42:09you know, making my rounds

00:42:11with compliance

00:42:12and then with privacy

00:42:13because all four of us

00:42:14are needed when it comes

00:42:16to this type of,

00:42:17you know, in a security event.

00:42:19We're all needed

00:42:20and we all play that role.

00:42:22So that's one of the first things

00:42:24that I would say,

00:42:25make sure there's a good

00:42:26relationship built

00:42:27between the attorney

00:42:28and the security team,

00:42:30at least the security lead

00:42:32because that's just

00:42:33a critical part.

00:42:34You know, the thing

00:42:35that we've uncovered

00:42:37and already shown,

00:42:39I think the audience,

00:42:40how much we have to go through

00:42:42in the CSO role

00:42:43or the security lead role

00:42:45of an organization.

00:42:47But there's so much more

00:42:48even behind that

00:42:49from the legal standpoint

00:42:51and we haven't even

00:42:52began to touch

00:42:54the class action lawsuits

00:42:56that are now probably

00:42:57being even more critical

00:42:58than what's being held

00:42:59against the, you know,

00:43:01OCR coming in

00:43:02and OCR is going

00:43:03to happen anyway.

00:43:04You have a breach,

00:43:05OCR is there.

00:43:06That's an automatic thing.

00:43:07What happens post all of that

00:43:08with all the potential class

00:43:10action lawsuits

00:43:11that are coming in

00:43:12and other attorneys

00:43:13now asking what's going on

00:43:14with your program

00:43:15and how are you going

00:43:16to defend that part

00:43:17of the program.

00:43:18So, you know,

00:43:19that's just a whole other

00:43:20topic.

00:43:21So that's a great.

00:43:22So, Jennifer,

00:43:23one of the things

00:43:24I think I'm hearing

00:43:25is that the lawyer

00:43:26should take the time

00:43:27to tell the security people

00:43:28this is the information

00:43:29we actually need

00:43:30to respond to the regulators.

00:43:32And it sounds like to me

00:43:33that the chief security officers

00:43:35or stakeholders

00:43:36are more than happy

00:43:37to work with them

00:43:38to help them get that

00:43:39or help them

00:43:40put the right things.

00:43:41But it sounds like there

00:43:42needs to be that

00:43:43definite conversation

00:43:44to build that.

00:43:45But any other thoughts

00:43:46or recommendations

00:43:47for the security professionals

00:43:49from their lands

00:43:50or for the lawyers?

00:43:52Yeah, my other one,

00:43:53I'm sorry,

00:43:54Jennifer,

00:43:55my other one would be

00:43:56that when

00:43:58and it's already been stated

00:44:00here about the contractual

00:44:01side of these relationships.

00:44:03But I think one of the first

00:44:05things that also should

00:44:06be done

00:44:07when you're talking

00:44:08about vendor

00:44:09management

00:44:10is that up front

00:44:11when you're screening

00:44:12potential new vendors,

00:44:14all that should be

00:44:15disclosed up front

00:44:16for a proper review

00:44:17from the security

00:44:18side of the house.

00:44:19And that should be part

00:44:20of the contractual agreements

00:44:22that are going in place.

00:44:23And there should be

00:44:24more than just,

00:44:25you know,

00:44:26just more than your

00:44:27procurement department

00:44:28reviewing the contract

00:44:29and legal.

00:44:30It should be

00:44:31security and privacy

00:44:32and compliance

00:44:33also involved in the reviews.

00:44:35All right,

00:44:36good point.

00:44:37Jennifer, your thoughts here?

Automatically generated; it may contain errors.

Lesson notes

Introduction to HIPAA and the entities it covers.

Study materials

Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.

Study notes

What HIPAA and the Privacy Rule set out to do

HIPAA was enacted in 1996 in response to demand that private health information be protected. The Department of Health and Human Services published the Privacy Rule regulation in 2002. The core achievement was a national standard for protecting sensitive patient health information: a minimum floor of protection that applies across the country.

The United States treats health information differently from other personal data, creating a multi-layered system with its own privacy rule for healthcare. Lawyers need to understand who that system covers and how obligations flow between organizations.

Covered entities and business associates

The starting point is what an organization does with protected health information (PHI): how it collects or receives it and what it uses it for. HIPAA imposes different requirements on covered entities and business associates.

  • Covered entities include health plans, healthcare clearinghouses and healthcare providers. A health insurance company and a primary care physician are covered entities.
  • Business associates use PHI received from a covered entity to provide a service to it. If a physician outsources billing, the billing company receives PHI from the physician, not the patient, and uses it to collect payment on the physician's behalf. The physician is the covered entity and the billing company is the business associate.

In practice, status is often disputed. After incidents, organizations frequently ask whether they were truly the covered entity, the business associate, or neither, even if they signed a document titled "business associate agreement." A biotech or pharmaceutical company may not be a covered entity, while a laboratory that processes patient information is. The panel suggested this part of HIPAA would benefit from clearer drafting.

How breach information travels down the vendor chain

Consider a covered entity whose billing company (a business associate) uses third-party software to transfer data. The software provider, not the business associate, is compromised.

  • The technology company may initially decline to notify the business associate because it does not know whether that customer's data was affected.
  • Weeks later, it discovers the data was taken and notifies the business associate, which then notifies the covered entity.
  • The covered entity, twice removed from the incident, has no direct relationship with the technology company and little visibility into what happened.

The practical question is who tells whom what, and how the information ultimately reaches the patient, as the statute intends. A technology provider with many affected customers will not prioritize one organization's requests unless a contract requires it.

Vendor management programs and contract terms

Two tools address this problem:

  • A vendor management program that looks past the business associate to the vendors it uses in the information-sharing ecosystem, and vets whether they are appropriate to hold the data.
  • Contracts that specify how, when and what parties communicate. The agreement between a business associate and its subcontractor should require reporting within a narrow window so the business associate can report up to the covered entity, and should require cooperation with any investigation, including information sharing with both the business associate and the covered entity.

Other practical points:

  • Include a clause giving the right to obtain information about third-party technology tools the vendor uses. Without it, there is little leverage.
  • Use security questionnaires and third-party attestations such as SOC 2 and ISO reports to assess vendors' practices.
  • Disclose and review security up front when screening new vendors.
  • Have security, privacy and compliance, not just procurement and legal, review vendor contracts.

Why a covered entity should not fully delegate breach notification

The covered entity has the HIPAA obligation to notify individuals, regulators, the media and other third parties, and it needs information from downstream vendors to do so. It can negotiate for a business associate to send notifications, but it should never simply hand off the obligation entirely. The covered entity remains responsible for ensuring the content requirements are met, the deadline is met and the right parties are notified.

An OCR investigation will not stop at the Breach Notification Rule. It will examine compliance with the Security Rule and the Privacy Rule as well, and findings can later be used to argue that the board lacked appropriate oversight. Regulators that once kept to their own lanes, such as HHS and OCR on one side and the SEC on the other, are increasingly converging.

How lawyers and security leaders should work together

  • Lawyers should tell security teams exactly what information they need to respond to regulators, so it can be gathered quickly.
  • Security leaders should ask legal what they need in place to defend the organization if something happens.
  • Keep open lines of communication and regular touch points, with the security lead reporting current threats, risks and weaknesses, since those are what will be attacked and scrutinized.
  • Legal, compliance, privacy and security all have roles in a security event.

Beyond OCR, which reliably follows a breach, class action litigation increasingly tests how the security program was built and whether it can be defended.

Flashcards

13 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.

Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.

1 of 13

Practice quiz

Practice — not graded, not the final exam

Question 1 of 6A physician's practice outsources billing to a company that receives patient data from the practice. How are the parties classified?
Choose an answer to check it.