Legal Cyber Academy

HIPAA Privacy Rule: Protected Information and Permitted Disclosures

Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.

Up next

Proposed Changes to the HIPAA Privacy Rule
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.

00:44:39Yeah, I think the

00:44:40so we oftentimes

00:44:41see a rub

00:44:42between the different stakeholders

00:44:44when we have these

00:44:45events where we'll be

00:44:46talking to

00:44:47the CISO

00:44:48about who they've engaged

00:44:50and what they're doing

00:44:51and we will

00:44:53CISOs are getting better,

00:44:55but there is sometimes

00:44:56a disconnect in the legal

00:44:57reasons why

00:44:58the attorneys care.

00:44:59So what exactly

00:45:00does HIPAA

00:45:01impose on the organization

00:45:02and what are the lawyers

00:45:03looking out to do?

00:45:04Well, they're looking out

00:45:05to ensure that there's

00:45:06compliance

00:45:07with all legal

00:45:08obligations regarding

00:45:09the safeguarding

00:45:10of information policies

00:45:11and procedures,

00:45:12things like that.

00:45:13They're also looking out

00:45:14to make sure if there

00:45:15were some type of event

00:45:16involving a downstream

00:45:18organization,

00:45:19making sure that

00:45:20they find out

00:45:21as soon as possible

00:45:22of the event

00:45:23of the impact

00:45:24so that they can

00:45:25ensure compliance.

00:45:26Understanding

00:45:27contractually

00:45:28what the shifts

00:45:29in liability

00:45:30and responsibilities

00:45:31are so that

00:45:32the CISOs understand

00:45:33this is why

00:45:34the attorneys want

00:45:35because we have to notify

00:45:36whomever within a

00:45:37certain deadline

00:45:38provide whatever information

00:45:39it may be.

00:45:40But also ensuring

00:45:41that we're bringing

00:45:42in risk management

00:45:43to the conversation

00:45:44as well,

00:45:45and have the

00:45:46insurance piece

00:45:47that everybody at

00:45:48the organization,

00:45:49if there is some

00:45:50type of incident,

00:45:51they want to

00:45:52make sure the

00:45:53out-of-pocket exposure

00:45:54for the organization

00:45:55is as minimal as

00:45:56possible.

00:45:57And oftentimes the

00:45:58risk is shifted

00:45:59via insurance.

00:46:00So making sure

00:46:01the consents

00:46:02are being obtained,

00:46:03the vendors that

00:46:04we're working with

00:46:05are the ones that

00:46:06are approved by

00:46:07the carrier to ensure

00:46:08that the coverage

00:46:09is there for

00:46:10the organization

00:46:11to utilize.

00:46:12Right.

00:46:13And so taking

00:46:14all of these things

00:46:15we've talked about,

00:46:16I'm just going to,

00:46:17you know,

00:46:18they're HIPAA

00:46:19has these five

00:46:20titles of HIPAA

00:46:21really looking at

00:46:22the privacy and security,

00:46:23which is Title II,

00:46:24right, where it's

00:46:25very prescriptive,

00:46:26privacy rule,

00:46:27breach notification rule,

00:46:28security rule,

00:46:29transaction and code

00:46:30set rules,

00:46:31like there's a

00:46:32litany of things

00:46:33that are stated and

00:46:34right, the privacy rule

00:46:35I think we've sort of

00:46:36touched on, but it,

00:46:37you know, it created

00:46:38this national standard,

00:46:39right, of when you

00:46:40collect personal,

00:46:41you know, public health,

00:46:42you know, this

00:46:43is where the interesting

00:46:44part is an individual's

00:46:45authorization is a

00:46:46necessary component of it.

00:46:48That gets really interesting,

00:46:50right, because that's

00:46:51the fifth component,

00:46:52right, and so

00:46:53a cover cannot

00:46:54be required to

00:46:55disclose PHI without

00:46:56an individual's

00:46:57authorization, right,

00:46:59for the following

00:47:00purposes, right, and

00:47:01they list these out,

00:47:02treatment, blah,

00:47:03so on and so forth.

00:47:04But then when you

00:47:05fast forward, right,

00:47:06provision five,

00:47:07it's that, you know,

00:47:08they have a bunch

00:47:09of provisions here and

00:47:10there's 12 national,

00:47:11you know, priority

00:47:12management, right,

00:47:13you know, without,

00:47:14and these are the

00:47:1512 law enforcement

00:47:16and all of these

00:47:17other things, right.

00:47:18One interesting

00:47:19question is can

00:47:20under that, if

00:47:21there's a data

00:47:22breach, can law

00:47:23enforcement disclosure

00:47:24be fit under that?

00:47:25I tend to say not so

00:47:27much, but you know

00:47:28what, everybody,

00:47:29it doesn't hurt to

00:47:30ask.

00:47:31But the point being

00:47:32is that in 2013,

00:47:33they created this

00:47:34HIPAA High Tech Act,

00:47:36and this is this

00:47:37whole thing about

00:47:38obligations being

00:47:39extended to the

00:47:40business associates.

Automatically generated; it may contain errors.

Lesson notes

Protected information, permitted uses, and disclosures.

Study materials

Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.

Study notes

Why CISOs and lawyers see HIPAA incidents differently

When a healthcare organization suffers an incident, there is often friction between stakeholders. A CISO focuses on who has been engaged and what is being done technically, while the attorneys are tracking legal obligations that the security team may not fully appreciate. CISOs are getting better at this, but closing the gap requires explaining why the lawyers care.

The lawyers are working to ensure:

  • Compliance with legal safeguarding obligations, including the policies and procedures HIPAA requires for protecting information.
  • Prompt knowledge of downstream events. If an organization further down the vendor chain has an incident, the lawyers need to learn about it as soon as possible so the organization can meet its own obligations.
  • A clear view of contractual shifts in liability and responsibility, so everyone understands why the organization must notify particular parties within particular deadlines and provide particular information.

How insurance shapes HIPAA incident response

Risk management belongs in the conversation. Organizations want to keep out-of-pocket exposure from an incident as low as possible, and much of that risk is shifted through insurance. To preserve coverage, the response team must:

  • Obtain the consents the policy requires.
  • Use vendors approved by the insurance carrier.

Failing to do either can leave the organization paying for a response that it expected to be covered.

The structure of HIPAA Title II

HIPAA has five titles. The one most relevant to privacy and security is Title II, which is highly prescriptive and includes:

  • The Privacy Rule
  • The Breach Notification Rule
  • The Security Rule
  • The Transactions and Code Sets Rules

Individual authorization and permitted disclosures under the Privacy Rule

The Privacy Rule created a national standard governing protected health information. A central component is the individual's authorization: as a general matter, a covered entity needs the individual's authorization to use or disclose PHI, subject to defined exceptions.

The rule lists purposes for which PHI may be used or disclosed without authorization, beginning with treatment, and it identifies a set of national priority purposes, such as disclosures to law enforcement, for which disclosure is permitted under specified conditions.

That raises a practical question: after a data breach, can sharing information with law enforcement fit within the permitted law enforcement disclosures? The view offered was that it likely does not fit comfortably, though it does not hurt for counsel to ask the question and analyze it on the facts.

How the HITECH Act extended HIPAA to business associates

The HITECH Act extended HIPAA obligations directly to business associates. That change is a major reason the classification questions discussed elsewhere in this course matter so much: business associates now carry their own compliance obligations, not merely contractual promises to the covered entities they serve.

For counsel, the practical lessons are:

  • Know which HIPAA rules apply to each organization in a data flow.
  • Make sure contracts reflect who must notify whom, how fast, and with what information.
  • Bring security, legal, risk management and insurance together before an incident so each understands the others' requirements.

Flashcards

11 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.

Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.

1 of 11

Practice quiz

Practice — not graded, not the final exam

Question 1 of 5During an incident, the CISO engages a forensic firm not on the insurer's approved list. What is the main risk?
Choose an answer to check it.