Navigating HIPAA: Guide to the Privacy Rule
Lesson 4 of 4
Proposed Changes to the HIPAA Privacy Rule
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Sign in to take the examPass it for a verifiable Certificate of CompletionThen
- Behind the Lens: Ethics of Surveillance and FTC Proposed RegulationDaniel B. Garrie, Wayne Matus and 2 others
- Understanding the CCPA and What Lies AheadDaniel B. Garrie, Mark Mermelstein and 2 others
- Legal Issues to Consider at the Board Level: Cybersecurity and Data PrivacyDaniel B. Garrie, David A. Cass and 2 others
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:47:41But now what's
00:47:42happening in 2020,
00:47:43they proposed rulemaking,
00:47:45this process for
00:47:46modifying the privacy
00:47:48rule to, you know,
00:47:49basically allow better
00:47:51information sharing
00:47:52between.
00:47:53So basically, if I go
00:47:55to one hospital and
00:47:56I go to another,
00:47:57it doesn't require
00:47:58an act of Congress
00:47:59from the know that
00:48:00I had massive surgery
00:48:01and this is my
00:48:02blood type and this
00:48:03was whatever,
00:48:04to streamline it.
00:48:05I think that was sort
00:48:06of part of the
00:48:07intent here, right,
00:48:08and to facilitate
00:48:09those things.
00:48:11What happened, you know,
00:48:12then they did all of
00:48:13this and then,
00:48:14you know, not,
00:48:15you don't get everything
00:48:16you want, right,
00:48:17but providing this
00:48:18information and then
00:48:20to post estimated
00:48:21schedules and access
00:48:23to the PHI and all
00:48:24of these things.
00:48:25But one of the things
00:48:26that, you know,
00:48:27and then, like,
00:48:28because everything moves
00:48:29so fast in the government,
00:48:30you know,
00:48:31I think it's supposed to be,
00:48:33it may have been
00:48:34released, I've been
00:48:35fairly in the weeds
00:48:36of late, but,
00:48:37you know,
00:48:38it's basically to
00:48:39reduce the burden.
00:48:40I'm not exactly sure
00:48:41how this reduces
00:48:42the burden, but,
00:48:43you know,
00:48:44maybe I'm not as smart
00:48:45as the people that
00:48:46wrote it.
00:48:47But, you know,
00:48:48one of the interesting
00:48:49things for me is
00:48:50if you're a CISO
00:48:52and, you know,
00:48:53because you see
00:48:54training employees,
00:48:55right, and you have,
00:48:56you know,
00:48:57these other things,
00:48:58these time frames
00:48:59for providing patients
00:49:00access to their
00:49:01information, right?
00:49:02How does that actually
00:49:03at a practical level,
00:49:04when you're looking
00:49:05at the privacy rule
00:49:06and all these pieces
00:49:07that come together
00:49:08and you're trying
00:49:09to manage it all, right?
00:49:10And we can take
00:49:11the pixel litigation,
00:49:12right?
00:49:13I see that privacy rule,
00:49:14right?
00:49:15There's these huge
00:49:16sets of cases today
00:49:17about, oh,
00:49:18you used the pixel,
00:49:19we got all,
00:49:20you know, whatever, okay?
00:49:21But they don't actually know
00:49:22what data went back
00:49:23and forth, 99.
00:49:24I mean, there's a lot
00:49:25of missing steps
00:49:26and a lot of the assumptions
00:49:27in pixel litigation
00:49:28that are imputed
00:49:29or upon information
00:49:30and belief, I guess,
00:49:31is what, you know,
00:49:32having mediated
00:49:33several of these,
00:49:34and for me,
00:49:35so for the non-lawyer,
00:49:36right, the technical people,
00:49:37to make a complaint
00:49:38and file a complaint
00:49:39just has to be
00:49:40information and belief.
00:49:41And so it doesn't,
00:49:43you know,
00:49:44you believe it to be true
00:49:45but you don't know
00:49:46it to be true, right?
00:49:47So when you think about
00:49:49all of these things
00:49:50and the proposed rule chains
00:49:51to reduce the burden, right?
00:49:53I mean, my question is,
00:49:55you know,
00:49:56I covered a whole lot
00:49:57of information here,
00:49:58but what do you think,
00:49:59you know,
00:50:00how does that actually work
00:50:01in an operational level?
00:50:03I mean, also, like,
00:50:04you're running,
00:50:05and Dave,
00:50:06you guys are running
00:50:07security organizations,
00:50:08and Jennifer,
00:50:09how do you advise your client,
00:50:10right?
00:50:11How does that actually work?
00:50:12I guess,
00:50:13honestly, your client
00:50:14is the company,
00:50:15and you work,
00:50:16and Dave,
00:50:17you both work with Legal.
00:50:18You know,
00:50:19and Jennifer,
00:50:20how do you,
00:50:21on the flip side,
00:50:22you know,
00:50:23you're working,
00:50:24usually on cleanup,
00:50:25but like,
00:50:26if you're helping them
00:50:27create this program
00:50:28and put it in place,
00:50:29how do you help guide
00:50:30that conversation
00:50:31given these new requirements,
00:50:32right?
00:50:33Hospitals aren't renowned
00:50:34for quick turnaround
00:50:35and how that actually works.
00:50:36So maybe,
00:50:37Azul,
00:50:38and Jennifer,
00:50:39and Dave,
00:50:40if you want to pick
00:50:41any part of that
00:50:42and weigh in,
00:50:43I'd welcome your thoughts.
00:50:44Azul.
00:50:45So,
00:50:46this is the place
00:50:47where I think
00:50:48we can bring in
00:50:49a couple of IT lingo,
00:50:50like Agile,
00:50:51and efficiency and so forth,
00:50:53because one of the purposes
00:50:55of HIPAA,
00:50:56as it came out
00:50:57back in 1996,
00:50:59is efficient operation
00:51:02of the healthcare
00:51:06information for the patients,
00:51:08right?
00:51:09So,
00:51:10it is increased efficiency
00:51:11at this time,
00:51:12sharing information
00:51:13between different service providers
00:51:15and between hospitals
00:51:16and so forth.
00:51:17So from IT perspective,
00:51:19we do need to make sure
00:51:21that they are happening
00:51:22in a secure manner,
00:51:23they are happening
00:51:24in a compliant manner
00:51:26with all the cyber security bells
00:51:29and whistles,
00:51:30whether it's encryption,
00:51:31whether it's access authentication
00:51:33and all that good stuff.
00:51:35And so we have to think
00:51:36from that perspective.
00:51:38As far as
00:51:41the bridge notifications
00:51:43and things like that,
00:51:44when we think about the timing,
00:51:46we need to figure out
00:51:47what is the correct
00:51:49and practical timing
00:51:51from our standpoint,
00:51:53given our operations,
00:51:54given our resources
00:51:55and what have you,
00:51:57all those things.
00:52:00That's why, of course,
00:52:01we can get the guidance
00:52:03from our legal
00:52:04and legal counsel
00:52:05and compliance team as far as
00:52:07what does it mean?
00:52:08When do we do this
00:52:10and when do we do that?
00:52:12When does the clock start ticking?
00:52:15So that is a legal question
00:52:17that we would go back
00:52:18to our legal team
00:52:19that we would go back
00:52:20to a compliance team
00:52:21or privacy team
00:52:22and then get the information
00:52:24and it's not necessarily
00:52:26impossible from IT perspective,
00:52:28but what needs to be done
00:52:31in the practical scenario?
00:52:33Yeah, so it's not
00:52:35print this template
00:52:37and plug and play
00:52:38your organization's name
00:52:40and you're good to go.
00:52:41It's not that
00:52:42and it never should be that.
00:52:44You can't mad-lib
00:52:46HIPAA compliance,
00:52:48but ensuring that you're
00:52:50keeping up to speed
00:52:51with the evolution of the laws,
00:52:52it's not just looking at HIPAA.
00:52:54You need to be also thinking
00:52:55about the board oversight requirements
00:52:57that may be touched upon
00:52:59ambiguously in HIPAA,
00:53:01but there are other legal
00:53:02considerations that the organization
00:53:04needs to be making
00:53:05when they are reviewing their
00:53:06policies and procedures,
00:53:07when they are changing their policies
00:53:08and procedures,
00:53:09when they are implementing
00:53:10new safeguards
00:53:11or new practices
00:53:13and processes at their organization,
00:53:15ensuring that it's compliant
00:53:17with not only HIPAA,
00:53:18but all of the other laws
00:53:19that organizations need to
00:53:21need to be compliant with
00:53:22on the safeguard side
00:53:24and the incident response side.
00:53:27Now, maybe I'm looking at this
00:53:30a little too simplistic, Daniel,
00:53:32but these changes, to me,
00:53:34impact more of our privacy group
00:53:36and our compliance group
00:53:37than it does the security group
00:53:38because it is changes
00:53:39to the privacy rule.
00:53:40And, you know, for the most part,
00:53:42we're really intimate
00:53:44with the security rule
00:53:45of this side of the house
00:53:47and I'm glad to see
00:53:48that there's changes
00:53:49starting to occur within the HIPAA,
00:53:51but I'm really welcoming the day
00:53:53when some changes are starting
00:53:55to be proposed
00:53:56and made on that security rule
00:53:58because I think it's long overdue
00:54:00and technology's changed
00:54:02and I think it's time for that area
00:54:04of HIPAA to be revisited as well.
00:54:06Well, I appreciate the, you know,
00:54:16it took six years
00:54:17to get an amendment in the door,
00:54:19so I don't know if they're going to
00:54:21to revise it,
00:54:22but you guys make excellent points
00:54:24and one of the things
00:54:25that I think lawyers
00:54:26that are looking at the privacy rule,
00:54:28when we just stand back,
00:54:30just take a second,
00:54:31we stand back
00:54:32and the security rule and the,
00:54:34you know, litany of other things
00:54:35that fall under Title II, right,
00:54:37and the amendments
00:54:38and these other things is,
00:54:39how does that actually
00:54:40impact the business, the risk?
00:54:42What is actually driving it, right?
00:54:44You said sometimes they'd say
00:54:46they don't have the budget
00:54:47to implement X, Y, and Z,
00:54:48or there was no financial incentive
00:54:50or so on and so forth, right?
00:54:53Clearly, there's a financial incentive
00:54:55to comply with the new HIPAA amendment
00:54:58to give medical records
00:54:59in a prompter fashion
00:55:01and, you know, failure to commit that,
00:55:03can expel, you know,
00:55:04so there's these things changing.
00:55:06My question to you is,
00:55:07now that we've looked at the privacy rule
00:55:08and we recognize
00:55:09there's this larger change happening,
00:55:11how do you think you can drive,
00:55:13how does that conversation
00:55:14happen and get driven, right?
00:55:15Because I think Jennifer and Ozzle,
00:55:19and I'd love to hear
00:55:20all of your thoughts here,
00:55:21how do you drive that conversation?
00:55:24Lawyers looking at helping
00:55:25their healthcare organizations
00:55:27sort of manage this risk
00:55:28in this most practical way
00:55:30what are the things
00:55:31these in-house lawyers
00:55:32or even outside counsel
00:55:33needs to start thinking about
00:55:35given that, you know,
00:55:36we're talking about, yes,
00:55:38HIPAA may not be the best statute, Dave,
00:55:40I will give you that without a doubt,
00:55:43but that is the reality
00:55:44they're operating in, right?
00:55:46And like, you know,
00:55:48there has to be a broader approach
00:55:51or a more effective approach
00:55:52than what we're currently executing against
00:55:56because I don't think that it'll,
00:55:59as everything starts to coalesce,
00:56:01how does one actually deliver against that?
00:56:03And I mean, maybe Jennifer, then Dave,
00:56:06and Ozzle, your thoughts
00:56:07as we're heading towards
00:56:08the end of the hour here.
00:56:09If you don't mind, Daniel,
00:56:11I want to jump on that one real quick.
00:56:12I got really fresh on my mind.
00:56:14This goes back to what would I like
00:56:16for you attorneys to know.
00:56:18This kind of is one of those.
00:56:20And the idea of training your employees
00:56:24and training your users to compliance
00:56:26and all those security threats
00:56:27that are going on,
00:56:29there's so many organizations
00:56:30that don't understand that that is
00:56:33just like what Jennifer mentioned
00:56:35about board reporting is part of the law.
00:56:40Training your users is also part of HIPAA requirements.
00:56:44And there's so many organizations
00:56:46under that miss that.
00:56:47And I would like to see the attorneys
00:56:49start asking the questions,
00:56:51what kind of training is being provided?
00:56:54You would not believe
00:56:55how many organizations that I've been a part of
00:56:58and actually consulted with
00:57:00that they're cutting budgets
00:57:02for security training
00:57:04and they're cutting budgets for HIPAA
00:57:06or they're saying we don't have time
00:57:08on new employee.
00:57:10We don't have enough time
00:57:11for new employees to come in
00:57:12to sit and talk with them
00:57:14about all these requirements and training.
00:57:17And they're not understanding it.
00:57:19You're not supposed to have a choice here.
00:57:21HIPAA is requiring you to do this.
00:57:23And so many times that gets overlooked
00:57:26and not enough time and substance
00:57:28is spent with the employees to understand
00:57:30what they're going to be required to do.
00:57:35So that's the big area.
00:57:37So building on what Dave said,
00:57:38I know we only have a few moments left,
00:57:40but building on what Dave said
00:57:41and what I said a few moments ago,
00:57:43ensuring there's a conversation
00:57:44where the attorneys are explaining
00:57:46to the non-attorneys legally
00:57:48what are the requirements of the organization.
00:57:50Dave's exactly right.
00:57:51Trading is not an addressable safeguard.
00:57:54Trading is required.
00:57:55Trading is something that any regulatory agency
00:57:58investigating an event
00:57:59is going to ask about now.
00:58:01What kind of training was provided
00:58:03and why didn't that training stop
00:58:05this event from happening?
00:58:06The worst answer you can have is,
00:58:07well, there was no training provided,
00:58:09so therefore the lack of training
00:58:11isn't going to stop this event from happening
00:58:13because they had no idea.
00:58:14That's not the answer
00:58:15that you want to be providing.
00:58:16The training is absolutely required,
00:58:18but as part of this training
00:58:19and as part of the annual risk assessment
00:58:20there should be a conversation happening
00:58:22where the attorneys are saying,
00:58:24in layman's terms, legally,
00:58:26this is what we are required to do
00:58:28as a result of our regulatory framework
00:58:32and as an organization,
00:58:33what steps are we taking
00:58:34to ensure compliance with that?
00:58:36Understanding there are many
00:58:37that are required, not addressable,
00:58:39and it's not optional for organizations
00:58:41to take those steps.
00:58:42If you roll the dice and just see,
00:58:45am I going to get caught,
00:58:46that's not the approach
00:58:48that I would ever recommend
00:58:49a client take.
00:58:50I think that speaks to why having
00:58:54a law firm help you navigate it.
00:58:58I think today more than before,
00:59:00having outside counsel help you
00:59:03and your security team
00:59:05review your controls,
00:59:06your procedures,
00:59:07and having an audit done
00:59:10where legal is instrumental
00:59:12and reviewing and doing part
00:59:14of that analysis
00:59:15becomes more and more important
00:59:17as the risk certainly seems
00:59:18to be growing and increasing,
00:59:20but also I'll leave you for the last,
00:59:22the final last comments here
00:59:24as we wrap up here.
00:59:25I want to be respectful
00:59:26of everyone's time.
00:59:27Sure.
00:59:28So just building on Dave and Jen
00:59:30just mentioned, absolutely,
00:59:32I agree with all of them.
00:59:34So along with training,
00:59:36there is a component
00:59:38which is also awareness,
00:59:39and then the other component
00:59:41is the education.
00:59:42So these three components
00:59:44need to work together.
00:59:46If there is no budget for training,
00:59:48be creative and provide
00:59:50the education and awareness
00:59:52in some fashion.
00:59:54So that is not an option
00:59:56that needs to be done.
00:59:58But then what also
01:00:00the organizations can do
01:00:01and what I normally try to do is
01:00:04I try to take things out
01:00:06from the context of legal
01:00:08and compliance eyes
01:00:10and try to put them into
01:00:11the perspective of business.
01:00:13It is the cost of business.
01:00:15It is not only in legal
01:00:16and it is a cost of business
01:00:18that we have to do X, Y and Z
01:00:20in the space of security,
01:00:22in the space of risk management.
01:00:25It is a business risk
01:00:26that we try to mitigate
01:00:28through a number of different ways.
01:00:30So as we put this
01:00:32into the context of business,
01:00:35operations, profitability,
01:00:37and revenue for the company,
01:00:39I think they then all
01:00:41start to make sense
01:00:43for the senior management
01:00:44as well as for the regular
01:00:45users to accept the subjects
01:00:50and the teaching lines
01:00:52or awareness lines
01:00:54as well as the senior management
01:00:56to provide that kind of resources,
01:00:59whether it is a budget
01:01:01or a tool or what have you.
01:01:04That is an excellent point.
01:01:05So I thank you all so much
01:01:07for your time.
01:01:08I really hope people
01:01:09listen to this.
01:01:10If you do have any further
01:01:11questions, please feel free
01:01:13to email any of the panelists
01:01:14directly.
01:01:15I am sure they are happy
01:01:16to follow up
01:01:17as long as you are not trying
01:01:18to sell them something.
01:01:20Thank you all again
01:01:21so much for your time
01:01:22and I wish everybody
01:01:24a great rest of the day.
01:01:27Take care.
01:01:29Thank you.
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Lesson notes
Anticipated changes and their impact on healthcare cybersecurity.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
What the proposed Privacy Rule changes aim to do
In 2020, a proposed rulemaking began a process to modify the HIPAA Privacy Rule. The stated goals were to allow better information sharing among providers and to reduce burden. The practical aim is simple: a patient who moves from one hospital to another should not face an ordeal for the second hospital to learn about prior surgery, blood type or other essential history.
The proposals also address timeframes for giving patients access to their own information and related transparency measures. One skeptical view was that it is not obvious how these changes actually reduce burden, given the operational work they require.
Operational challenges for security teams implementing the changes
One of HIPAA's original purposes was efficient handling of patient health information. Increased sharing among providers and hospitals must still happen securely and compliantly, which means applying:
- Encryption of data in transit and at rest.
- Access controls and authentication.
- Other standard security safeguards.
On timing, such as for breach notifications and patient access, IT teams need legal, compliance and privacy teams to answer the legal questions: what does a requirement mean, when must something be done, and when does the clock start? The security team then works out what is practical given operations and resources.
One view was that the proposed changes affect privacy and compliance groups more than security, since they modify the Privacy Rule. Security leaders expressed a wish for the Security Rule to be revisited, given how much technology has changed.
Why HIPAA compliance cannot be copied from a template
HIPAA compliance is not a matter of printing a template and inserting the organization's name. Organizations must keep up with how the law is evolving, and HIPAA is not the only consideration:
- Board oversight requirements, which HIPAA touches only ambiguously, also apply.
- Other laws governing safeguards and incident response must be considered whenever policies and procedures are reviewed or changed, or new safeguards and processes are implemented.
Pixel tracking litigation and the Privacy Rule
A large body of litigation now alleges that healthcare organizations used tracking pixels that transmitted patient information. From the perspective of someone who has mediated several of these cases, many complaints rest on assumptions pleaded on information and belief: the plaintiffs believe data was transmitted but do not actually know what data went back and forth. Technical professionals should understand that a complaint may be filed on belief rather than established fact, which shapes how these disputes unfold.
Workforce training is a required HIPAA safeguard
A recurring gap is training. Training the workforce is a HIPAA requirement, not an optional or addressable safeguard, yet many organizations overlook it:
- Some cut budgets for security and HIPAA training.
- Some claim there is no time to train new employees on the requirements.
- Others spend too little time and substance on what employees must actually do.
Any regulator investigating an incident will ask what training was provided and why it did not prevent the event. The worst possible answer is that there was no training. Lawyers should ask what training is being provided, and as part of training and the annual risk assessment, explain in plain terms what the regulatory framework requires and what steps the organization is taking to comply. Many safeguards are required, not addressable, and "rolling the dice" on getting caught is not an acceptable strategy.
Training, awareness and education together
Training works best alongside two related components:
- Awareness of current threats and expectations.
- Education that builds understanding over time.
If there is no budget for formal training, organizations should be creative and still deliver awareness and education in some form. It is not optional.
Framing HIPAA compliance as a business risk
Security and compliance requirements gain traction when presented in business terms. Rather than framing them only through legal and compliance eyes, present security and risk management as a cost of doing business and a business risk to be mitigated. When tied to operations, profitability and revenue, the requirements make more sense to senior management, which then provides budget and tools, and to employees, who are more likely to accept training.
For counsel, the larger takeaway is that outside counsel and legal involvement in reviewing controls and procedures, including through audits where legal is part of the analysis, is becoming more important as the risk grows.
Flashcards
11 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 11
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam