Cyber Attacks, Data Breaches, and Insider Threats
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Why Private Clubs Are TargetsTranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:00:04Legal Cyber Academy would like to welcome to today's program, Defending the Club, Cybersecurity Strategies for Private Golf & Country Clubs.
00:00:12Today's speakers are Daniel B. Garrie, Founder of Law & Forensics, Neutral JAMS, and Adjunct Faculty at Harvard.
00:00:19Mark Mermelstein, Partner at Holmes, Athey, Cowan & Mermelstein LLP, and Daniel K. Gelb, Partner at Gelb & Gelb LLP.
00:00:27The program materials can be found under the Supplements tab. Thank you for joining us.
00:00:33And as a disclaimer, this is not legal advice, nor should it be considered legal advice.
00:00:38This presentation and the comments contained therein represent only the personal views of the participants as spoken and do not reflect those of their employers or clients.
00:00:47This presentation is offered for educational and informational uses only, soliciting speakers is strictly prohibited.
00:00:54If I could just then have each of you introduce yourselves, starting with Daniel Garrie.
00:01:00Well, thank you so much. It's a pleasure.
00:01:03I work in cybersecurity through Law & Forensics on a daily basis.
00:01:09I work, I also teach at Harvard Cybersecurity, FinTech, and the likes.
00:01:16It's a pleasure and privilege, and I am lucky my other panelists are much smarter and better looking than me.
00:01:21So I'll turn it over to them to introduce themselves.
00:01:24Daniel Gelb.
00:01:26Thank you so much for having me. Really appreciate it. Looking forward to this interesting topic.
00:01:33My name is Dan Gelb. I'm a partner at Gelb & Gelb LLP.
00:01:37My parents started the firm in 1987, joined up with them in 2006.
00:01:42Before that, I was an assistant district attorney in Massachusetts.
00:01:45Most of my practice concentrates on state and federal criminal defense, regulatory proceedings, and complex civil litigation in state and federal courts.
00:01:55As well as a lot of academic and student conduct defense work.
00:01:59Wonderful. And Mark?
00:02:01Hi. Thank you so much for having me. It's really a privilege. My name is Mark Mermelstein.
00:02:08I'm an attorney. I've been practicing for about 25 years now, both in New York and California.
00:02:16Mainly in the white collar space, white collar criminal and regulatory work.
00:02:24But I've also done a fair amount of cyber security work, both pre-litigation counseling folks on the victim's side, much less so on the perpetrator's side.
00:02:39And post-complaint handling some civil litigation related to that as well.
00:02:49So looking forward to an interesting discussion.
00:02:52Thank you all for being here today.
00:02:54So today we'll be discussing just the introduction to cyber security, the threat landscape, and strategies to manage and mitigate cyber risk.
00:03:05So what is cyber security in the broadest strokes, Daniel?
00:03:10Well, we can click our heels together three times. No.
00:03:13So cyber security at the most practical level is about securing digital devices, whether it's your home, whether it's your car, whether it's your networks, whether it's your computer systems.
00:03:23Whether it's your golf carts, whether it's your country club ordering system, whether it's whatever it is, it's securing them from malicious actors or actors.
00:03:32Sometimes we wouldn't say malicious because your own internal people can be involved in cyber security issues either knowingly or otherwise.
00:03:41But that's a general gist of it.
00:03:43But I'll turn it over to Galvin. I'm sorry, Daniel and Mark to Wayne as well.
00:03:47Go ahead, Mark.
00:03:52Go ahead.
00:03:54Sure. So good definition.
00:03:58I think at its core, cyber security is really just another form of security that folks need to provide to their clients.
00:04:14Whether it's, you know, for years, folks have perhaps needed to provide some physical security for their clients, whether they're business partners or whatnot.
00:04:28And the world has moved to cyber security, their obligations to provide it, and there's liability if it's not provided.
00:04:40I also think that that's a great point.
00:04:43I think that it's also a subject matter of, you know, ensuring against things that are happening in the background that you're not aware of.
00:04:55Unlike physical security, where you can identify something that could be potentially problematic on one's property or in a particular setting or environment.
00:05:05With cyber security, our digital world that we all operate in on a daily basis, there's all sorts of stuff going on in the background.
00:05:14So it's also not only about just what could be harmful that you can already identify, but it's the stuff that's going on simultaneously in day to day life that we are not aware of.
00:05:29Let me just jump in with one further thought there.
00:05:32I think the biggest difference between the physical and the cyber, not only as Dan alludes to the fact that we may not be aware of what's going on, but it's the ability to perpetrate a wrongful act remotely.
00:05:46So you have your threat actors who can often be in Russia, in China, thousands of miles away, and potentially beyond the reach of local law enforcement or local courts that really introduce an additional element of risk and a complicating factor when you're trying to deal with this threat landscape.
00:06:15So what's the difference between a cyber attack and a data breach? Mark?
00:06:22Sure. So a cyber attack, there can be many different forms of attacks, some of which may result in a data breach.
00:06:40So cyber attacks can take the form of sort of a ransomware attack, where the goal is to hold the victim's data hostage, ultimately to get some money out of the victim.
00:07:04You can have denial of service attacks. It's another form of attack where you're shutting down the victim's website by flooding the victim website with a lot of acts trying to access the victim's website on multiple fronts, which ultimately shuts down the victim's website, try to leverage that.
00:07:25Or the purpose of the attack can be to harvest data and then use that data for a whole variety of malicious purposes.
00:07:36So some of those can result in the release of data, which then triggers some legal obligations separately related to a data breach.
00:07:47So cyber attack, I view as a kind of a broader term, won't necessarily result in a data breach, but can certainly can result in a data breach.
00:07:59That's good.
00:08:05So the threats to the organizations, I know we've touched upon malicious actors, but, and this slide is talking about the insider threat for the, where do you see, or what is the insider threat to organizations, Dan?
00:08:24I think in particular, sort of even just the unknowing, or for the lack of a better term, maybe negligence of employees not being aware or fully trained on protocols relative to security or the actual business environment is one that isn't up to speed or doesn't have a robust cyber security plan in place.
00:08:54So insiders such as, for example, on this slide here, you have a human error being subject to spoofing, phishing type of attempts by even whether they're done by bots or specifically targeted a potential victim by an outsider with a motive.
00:09:21People day to day, you know, sometimes may just even click on something thinking that it looks like exactly something that they are expecting, or that they typically would use, you know, a link to, you know, access.
00:09:37But I think that's one of the major, major threats and sources of vulnerability is just sort of your average everyday insider.
00:09:49And there's been recent examples of the vulnerabilities from third parties and vendors and especially as it pertains to country clubs, golf clubs with that rely on third parties, this idea that your security practices need to be validated internally and also what your practices are for third parties.
00:10:11Have you seen, Daniel, a rise in awareness of people and organizations looking to reevaluate their third party practices?
00:10:22Well, this is really interesting. So I used to think country clubs who cares and whatever and the likes and what I've come to appreciate is that a lots of people are members of country clubs.
00:10:33They have a whole lot of personal information and your kids information and your kids friends information and all of these things that you don't really think about, but you know, you go to a tennis and then you sign a waiver and you put your kids names in and your ages in and you sign the release.
00:10:48And so, but it turns out that a lot of these country clubs and golf clubs and whatever, they use third party services to manage the platform.
00:10:57And what happens is, is that in particular with country clubs and the likes, they don't actually vet them, right?
00:11:03They're just fully reliant on this third party software platform to manage it and handle that.
00:11:09And they don't have any way of managing that response.
00:11:12And so, particularly in those organizations, right, it's a much larger risk because they haven't really vetted the vendor, right?
00:11:21They haven't done a deep dive on the vendor cybersecurity protocols, but they have all of my kids information and I have two young kids.
00:11:28So I've become acutely aware of how much information a country club can have.
00:11:33And they're really relying on humans, right?
00:11:36They're really relying on the people putting in the data, the third parties and the vendors that are managing it.
00:11:41And that diligence really is overlooked and should be looked at with more scrutiny, certainly in that space.
00:11:49I also think on that that you have a lot of users that don't necessarily think that their online access to their country club portal is something where they have to put in a robust password.
00:12:04So my sense is that most folks have a pretty robust password or two factor authentication for their bank, their online bank access.
00:12:14But they're not necessarily thinking about a robust password for their country club access.
00:12:21And so you can have situations where someone's using the same non-robust password on multiple different platforms, right?
00:12:33And so once someone, a malicious actor is able to access that, find that commonly used password, non-robust password, and then try it out everywhere else, that same person has online access.
00:12:51And that's an entry point that's ultimately dependent on the users not using the same password everywhere, even on accounts that they don't think are necessarily important.
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Lesson notes
Explains how a cyber attack differs from a data breach, the forms attacks take such as ransomware, denial of service, and data harvesting, and how weak or reused passwords open the door at private clubs.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
What cybersecurity means for a private club
At the most practical level, cybersecurity means securing digital devices and systems from malicious actors: homes, cars, networks and computers, and for a club, everything from golf carts to the club's ordering system. Threats do not always come from malicious outsiders; a club's own people can be involved, knowingly or not.
Cybersecurity is another form of security that organizations owe the people they serve. Clubs have long provided physical security for members and business partners, and the obligation now extends to cyber security, with liability if it is not provided.
Two features distinguish cyber from physical security:
- Invisible activity. A physical threat on the property can often be spotted. In the digital world, a great deal happens in the background that no one is aware of, so security must address risks that are not yet visible.
- Remote attackers. Threat actors can operate from thousands of miles away, for example from Russia or China, often beyond the reach of local law enforcement and courts. That adds risk and complicates the response.
Cyber attacks versus data breaches
A cyber attack is the broader term and takes many forms:
- Ransomware, which holds the victim's data hostage to extract payment.
- Denial of service, which floods a website with access attempts until it shuts down, giving the attacker leverage.
- Data harvesting, which steals data for later malicious use.
Some attacks result in the release of data, which is a data breach and triggers separate legal obligations. An attack does not necessarily produce a breach, but it can.
The insider threat and everyday human error
One of the biggest sources of vulnerability is the average, everyday insider. The risk is often not malice but negligence or lack of training: employees who are not fully trained on security protocols, or a business environment without a robust cybersecurity plan. Employees fall for spoofing and phishing, whether automated or targeted by an outsider with a motive, and click links that look like exactly what they expected to receive.
Why clubs hold sensitive data and rely on unvetted vendors
Clubs hold far more personal information than people realize: information about members, their children and their children's friends, collected through activities such as tennis waivers and releases listing names and ages.
Many clubs use third-party software platforms to manage that data but do not vet those vendors. They rely entirely on the platform without a deep look at its cybersecurity protocols and without a way to manage the response if something goes wrong. Security practices need to be validated internally, and clubs should also scrutinize their practices for third parties.
Password reuse on club portals
Many members use strong passwords or two-factor authentication for online banking but do not think their club portal needs the same care. When a member reuses the same weak password across platforms, an attacker who obtains it from one site can try it everywhere else that person has online access. A club portal can become the entry point. Members, and clubs that run portals, should treat these accounts as worth protecting with unique, robust passwords.
Flashcards
10 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 10
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam