Tabletop Exercises, Vendors, and Basic Controls
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Cyber Insurance and the Incident Response PlanTranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:00:00So I think sometimes using a tabletop or scenario or in their onboarding process, sort of walk through the role specific things so they're aware.
00:00:09And then for your senior leadership, run them through a tabletop because they have no idea.
00:00:16Like, I can promise you this much. Nobody at a country club has any idea how to respond to a cyber incident.
00:00:23And so running through a simulated cyber scenario is a very eye opening experience.
00:00:29Just for everybody, including the board members, because the board members do have liability.
00:00:35And I don't, there is insurance that covers the board members on the DNO and the other policies cover it.
00:00:43But, and I only know this because I'm mediating it.
00:00:46But, you know, I think running through that scenario is probably worthwhile.
00:00:52So, you know, how much coverage you have and what that looks like, right?
00:00:56I mean, everybody wants them to tender the policies.
00:00:59But I think knowing as first the board member and the senior management, how the insurance works and working through those things through a tabletop scenario is usually a very eye opening experience for them.
00:01:11Let me just jump in here on that.
00:01:14A couple of things to build on what Daniel's saying.
00:01:18The most interesting thing for me in doing these tabletop exercises is not necessarily how they respond, but who responds.
00:01:29What ends up happening is that the kind of the alpha person in the room ends up, you know, responding and making the decisions on how to respond.
00:01:41Even though that person may not necessarily have any clue on an appropriate response, because nobody's even thought about who is going to lead the response, right?
00:01:56The second thing that is what expert help are you going to get when you have to make a big decision?
00:02:07Are the people in the room the people that have the knowledge on how to respond?
00:02:12So one scenario I was involved in wasn't a country club, it was a retail shop, and their website was shut down.
00:02:23You could imagine a country club's website shut down being a problem.
00:02:27It was shut down because there was a denial of service attack, so the company's website was shut down, and if it's shut down, they're not making any sales.
00:02:38And there's a request for ransom in order to stop the attack.
00:02:47And the question is, does the company pay the ransom, right?
00:02:53How are they going to make that decision as to whether to pay the ransom? Who's going to make that decision?
00:03:00I actually got a call like, should we pay the ransom? And I said, hey, let me think about if I can figure out more information on the attackers.
00:03:11And I talked to a guy at the FBI who put me in touch with a different guy at the FBI who was actually investigating those very attackers.
00:03:23And he was able to tell me, the guys who are perpetrating this attack are out of Nigeria, and they rent the botnet that's causing the attack.
00:03:34So you need a series of computers to launch a denial of service attack, and they rent it by the hour.
00:03:42And what the FBI agent was telling me is, folks who don't pay the ransom where, after one hour or two hours, the attack usually ends because the hackers don't want to keep paying to rent the botnet if they're not getting any yield.
00:04:04Well, that was real intel that I was able to provide back to my clients so that they could make a decision, okay, we're not going to pay this ransomware attack.
00:04:16So I think it's important to think about if you're going to be in this situation where there's a simulated attack, who's going to be making the decisions, and who are you going to call for some expert guidance?
00:04:31And thinking about that in advance of an attack can be super, super important.
00:04:37That's great. Dan or Daniel, anything to add to that?
00:04:43Well, I think in addition, having a standard operating procedure for data security that's actually written and delineated with a breach response protocol for the club or for whatever organization, you know, we're dealing with.
00:05:02And cybersecurity insurance with a policy that has a point of contact for if there is a claim that needs to be submitted because sometimes, as I'm sure everyone here knows, you know, if you are the victim of a data breach and there's, let's say, significant credit card activity that's then disputed,
00:05:25you're going to want something that certifies that this was, in fact, subject to a breach for the credit reporting bureaus.
00:05:34So, you know, just to make sure that you actually have a standard operating procedure for cybersecurity for the club in place so it's not something that's honored in practice and not just in a breach.
00:05:48The idea we've touched upon, vendor management, you know, and securing your third party vendors with country clubs, you know, your payment processors, your third parties, the people that deliver your fruits, all this stuff and how it is really important.
00:06:03I know we've touched upon it.
00:06:07Daniel, what are some best practices, you know, that country clubs can start with in managing their vendor risk?
00:06:16Well, I think Mark's already said some of them, like, just learn how to write a good contract to transfer some of the risk. Do an independent cyber audit sort of so you know what you have and don't have from an insurance perspective, from a business perspective.
00:06:30Understand your basic systems.
00:06:33Work with your vendors to make sure that you've implemented. Make sure the board is fully in the loop.
00:06:38I would, to build on what Mark's saying, run a tabletop, like, with the board and the senior management so you can at least figure out what to do.
00:06:48Who do you need to tell? Like, how do you find all of the members? Like, it gets really complicated because most country clubs don't have good data governance so members leave and they keep it anyways and people die and they keep it anyways and the costs are much can be very high for notification and these other things.
00:07:06So I think running through those and, you know, and go through your vendors and manage that risk properly, I think would be a good place to start.
00:07:14I think vendor management is also highlights the importance of bringing in some legal assistance as well for this contract review.
00:07:25Making sure that these vendors that maybe have lasted 10 years, you know, the current group or board, making sure that those contract terms have security standards and if not, making amendments, something called like a data processing addendum or anything like that.
00:07:49Or at this point, you know, going through with contracts and attorneys, really what should then additionally country clubs be doing for their contracts in their review?
00:08:07Was that to me? I'm sorry.
00:08:12Oh, I'm sorry. I said Mark.
00:08:13Go ahead, Mark.
00:08:17Dan, please, you go ahead. I'll jump in afterwards.
00:08:22I think to make sure that
00:08:26Well, big ticket item is to make sure that whatever vendor with which you're dealing with, they themselves have liability insurance.
00:08:36There isn't a limitation on liability provision in whatever range contractual arrangement you have with them that is sort of like limits to like whatever the goods and services that are being provided.
00:08:51And that they themselves have, you know, the, you know, you get proof of coverage from them. But obviously, it depends on what type of vendor we're dealing with here, right?
00:09:01You know, so if it's like point of sale vendor where there's going to be a lot of information, you know, financial information stored and personal information about memberships.
00:09:11I would think that's probably different than I could be wrong, but I think it would probably be different than, let's say, an arrangement you have with like a food distribution service, let's say for right.
00:09:22Yeah, I think it's about two things.
00:09:28It's about financial responsibility.
00:09:32And it's about a representation that they're going to take care of the security associated with the data that the vendor is managing for the club.
00:09:46And that they're going to provide insurance, they're going to maintain insurance so that you're not then fighting with that vendor to cover the cost that there's a third party policy that already exists so that there's a bucket of money
00:10:04to deal with the after effects. Those to me are the two big buckets. The one other thing I would think about is when you're talking about credit cards and depending on whether they are the club is processing their own credit cards or they have a third party,
00:10:24there are representations that are being made to the credit card companies with respect to appropriate security and where the credit card data is being housed and companies clubs can have liability to the credit card companies separate and apart from customers
00:10:49or whatnot. And the risk there is the credit card company can ultimately cut off the club. And if a club's lifeblood is sort of having members pay for things through credit cards, that can be an awfully important area that needs to be handled properly.
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Lesson notes
Explains why club leaders and board members should run tabletop exercises, how to manage vendor and payment-processor risk, and which basic controls and contract terms to put in place.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
Tabletop exercises for club staff, leadership and boards
Training can be built into onboarding through role-specific scenarios so each employee knows what to do. Senior leadership and the board should go through a tabletop exercise, because people at most clubs have no idea how to respond to a cyber incident. A simulated scenario is eye opening.
Boards matter because board members have liability. Directors and officers policies and other policies may cover them, and a tabletop is a good way for board members and senior management to learn how the club's insurance actually works before they need it.
Two things a tabletop reveals:
- Who responds. Often the most forceful person in the room takes charge, even without any idea of the appropriate response, because no one decided in advance who would lead.
- What expert help is available. Are the people in the room the ones with the knowledge to make big decisions, and whom will they call for guidance?
A ransom decision informed by law enforcement intelligence
In one example involving a retail business, a denial-of-service attack shut down the company's website, halting sales, and the attackers demanded a ransom to stop. The question was whether to pay and who would decide. Counsel reached out to the FBI and was connected with an agent investigating those very attackers. The agent explained that the group, based in Nigeria, rented the botnet used for the attack by the hour; when victims did not pay, attacks usually ended within an hour or two because the attackers did not want to keep paying for the botnet without a return. With that intelligence the client decided not to pay.
The lesson: decide in advance who will make decisions during an attack and who you will call for expert guidance.
Written procedures and cyber insurance contacts
A club should have a written standard operating procedure for data security with a defined breach response protocol, practiced in daily operations rather than honored only on paper. Its cyber insurance policy should identify a point of contact for submitting a claim. After a breach, affected members disputing fraudulent card activity may need documentation certifying that the club suffered a breach, for example for credit reporting bureaus.
Managing vendor risk through contracts and audits
Clubs rely on many vendors: payment processors, point-of-sale providers, member platforms and even food distributors. Starting points for managing that risk:
- Write contracts that transfer risk. Review long-standing vendor contracts, some a decade old, for security standards and amend them where needed, for example with a data processing addendum. Legal help with contract review is worthwhile.
- Two key contract terms. First, financial responsibility: the vendor should carry its own liability insurance, provide proof of coverage, and the contract should not cap its liability at the value of the goods or services provided. Second, a representation that the vendor will secure the data it manages for the club, backed by insurance so there is a bucket of money for the aftermath rather than a fight with the vendor.
- Scale to the vendor. A point-of-sale vendor holding financial and member information warrants more protection than a food distribution service.
- Run an independent cyber audit to learn what the club has and lacks from insurance and business perspectives, and understand basic systems.
- Keep the board in the loop and run a tabletop with the board and senior management, including who must be told and how to find all members.
Poor data governance raises notification costs: clubs often keep records of members who have left or died, and finding and notifying everyone can be expensive.
Credit card obligations
Whether a club processes its own cards or uses a third party, it makes representations to the card companies about security and where card data is housed. A club can have liability to the card companies separate from its liability to members, and a card company can ultimately cut the club off. For a club whose lifeblood is members paying by card, handling that area properly is critical.
Flashcards
11 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 11
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam