Legal Cyber Academy

Why Private Clubs Are Targets

Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.

Up next

What a Breach Costs a Club: Member Data, Notification, and Training
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.

00:00:00That's a great point. I know we're going to touch upon the specifics with the country club.

00:00:05But really just cybersecurity is prominent and prevalent today.

00:00:10You know, this slide just shows the consequences of and how prominent data breaches are.

00:00:17You know, right now we have the global average cost of a data breach is 4.88 million.

00:00:23The U.S. leads all the other countries by the cost of the data breach.

00:00:29And having a data breach is now a common occurrence, right?

00:00:35We don't see it's the exception. It's pretty much what's the phrase, you know, if not now, when, or if.

00:00:42Why are country clubs just, should be, why should they be worried?

00:00:50You know, they're not the traditional victim or target in these cases.

00:00:55You know, Dan, what do you think?

00:00:59Well, I think that when you're dealing with clubs or other types of social organizations in general, they're more, you know, casual environments.

00:01:09You know, they're not designed necessarily to approach business operations always sort of like in a position of, you know, kind of as tactical measures like, you know, for example, like a medical practice

00:01:24or a law practice, right, or accounting or a bank.

00:01:27I mean, we're constantly concerned about what security practices are in place to make sure that there's two factor authentication, to make sure that we're redacting things, all that stuff, you know.

00:01:38So, you know, country clubs, you know, it's not all of them, of course, but a lot of social organizations, you know, they,

00:01:51there's a lot of integration between the day to day operations and what's being done socially, both in person as well as online.

00:02:00So I think there's just a lot of potential sort of holes in the fence, if you will, for people to find out about people, people to be able to go on social media, kind of see where, you know, some of them have, you know, directories that are published.

00:02:16They, you know, advertise or promote certain events.

00:02:20You know, there's ways of finding out sensitive information about people.

00:02:25Yeah, so this slide about the rising threat for clubs in 2017, the National Club Association surveyed its members and found that 41% had conducted a cybersecurity vulnerability assessment within the past year.

00:02:40The other statistics on this page kind of highlight that cybersecurity is being, isn't an issue that clubs are beginning to address.

00:02:51And, you know, it's been now eight years, if the National Club Association would do a secondary assessment or survey, I'd imagine these percentages would greatly improve.

00:03:05Well, just on that, I guess my question is how much are clubs willing to invest in a cybersecurity budget, right?

00:03:19Right.

00:03:20How much are club members willing to pay in extra dues so that their club has appropriate cybersecurity?

00:03:30And so to me, it suggests that the market hasn't necessarily caught up and the cybersecurity at clubs is probably more lax than at banks and law firms and medical practices,

00:03:48where they can, you know, they have a greater budget and a greater need to put up robust cybersecurity.

00:03:58I want to build on that just quickly as we keep going here.

00:04:04One of the more interesting things from where I sit, right, is that you go after the lowest hanging fruit, right?

00:04:10Used to be, you know, law firms, you know, were the easiest point of entry, right?

00:04:15And now I would say country clubs are certainly an easiest point of entry and they have a lot of data.

00:04:21People don't realize how much data a country club actually has, right?

00:04:25And so I agree with Mark.

00:04:27I don't think they're spending profuse amounts of money or even having some response plans or any of those things.

00:04:34I mean, I haven't got it.

00:04:36I mean, I just was no I'm dealing with two situations where different country clubs had to notify their members.

00:04:41And it's a very awkward situation, that process.

00:04:46But I can tell you, generally, there's a huge need for them to start thinking about that because there's, you know, they also don't have good data governance.

00:04:56So they have data from members that are dead and they got to notify their families that in the state.

00:05:01Like, I mean, it's kind of crazy when you start looking at the cost to them and a lot of them don't have insurance either.

00:05:08But and so that it gets even more complicated.

00:05:11So I think there's a huge need for the country clubs to really start looking and thinking about this.

00:05:17The other hurdle is that you also have a board who typically runs country clubs that maybe just elected homeowners or condo owners that aren't educated, that change every four or five years.

00:05:28So the outgoing administration maybe highlights cybersecurity.

00:05:32But then you, as Marx said, have to go through the hurdle of, well, what is it going to cost the members and assessment?

00:05:38Or would they rather put that money towards, you know, a new country club or a new tennis court?

00:05:44How much information and education is being pressed upon those that approve the budget to highlight a potential threat?

00:05:55I do think, though, that part of it can with a pretty minimal investment in time.

00:06:05To the extent, I mean, Daniel was pointing to the fact that the country club has a third party that's hosting the website, a third party that's managing this.

00:06:16Well, it seems to me that the risk it then what you can put in place is an allocation of risk so that that third party who's running the site, right, is responsible for any costs associated with a data breach.

00:06:36And that third party is required to purchase insurance.

00:06:42I agree 100 percent. But I can promise you, most country clubs don't have that.

00:06:47No, I don't disagree. But this my point is that it's not very expensive to get on the phone with your third party provider and demand that they actually have insurance in place and demand that they take responsibility for

00:07:09in the event that that there's a breach. Right. And so I agree. I think that's a great first step.

00:07:16I think they probably need to do an assessment or like do they have an incident response plan?

00:07:20How do they manage, you know, like some basic blocking and tackling to get their house in order?

00:07:25Maybe, you know, cost a fortune, but get those things done and get those things sort of managed properly because, you know, I think it's crazy when you start looking at like,

00:07:37you know, country clubs and all of these things, the amount of information they have is a lot and nobody in the and I don't I don't know anything about the legal marketplace for that or the services or anything.

00:07:47But it's kind of astounding to me that nobody actually looks at it. But general, I'll turn it over to you because I know we have a bunch of material to cover.

00:07:54Yeah, that's OK. So just to highlight, then, the fact that country clubs are being targeted for data breaches.

00:08:01On the slide, we have two recent ones from twenty twenty four for any bird and California where there were attackers that compromised member information specifically in one in Edenberg.

00:08:15The attackers obtained access to nine hundred and forty nine point four gigabytes of data and the other one in El Dorado.

00:08:25They exfiltrated twenty eight point nine gigabytes of data. So they country clubs are seeing are being attacked, are being susceptible to these malicious actors.

00:08:38I know we touched upon it, you know, at length regarding why country clubs are targets.

00:08:44I just want to kind of focus on just the vast amount of data that they do have in the different types.

00:08:51Dan, if you could just kind of go into why they are such a wealth of a treasure trove for malicious actors.

00:09:01Well, I think it depends, you know, depends on the club or the organization. Right. But I, of course.

00:09:08But I think sort of just for the sake of hypothetical, you know, there's an application process where if depending on how exclusive the club is that you're applying to is likely going to do an asset check or is going to do something to see whether or not

00:09:31it also depends also on whether or not some of these country clubs also have residential components to them, too. Right.

00:09:37So if you think some of these like large developments where there's a country club type of membership in addition to an actual residential area that's affiliated with it, they could be doing a due diligence on financial ability to pay assessment and dues and all that stuff.

00:09:57They're going to want credit card information. They're going to want all sorts of things depending on what type of platform that they have.

00:10:05I'm imagining that unless the particular club has a document, a document management and data destruction protocol in place, these things are probably either scanned into or just someone provides it to PDF.

00:10:24And it's on some server somewhere. You know, and for all you know, if someone's using a particular employee of the club is using a platform that's cloud based, that's not particularly secure.

00:10:40You know, you could get at people's credit card information at maybe tax returns, social security numbers, all sorts of stuff.

00:10:51I think one of the important issues that may also is the dad privacy aspect that some of the security and the use of this private information, financial, personal, right?

00:11:05They have all this information on members. So it's about why you're using it, how you're protecting it.

00:11:14But members don't ask. This is the crazy part of the whole thing. No member, like I only say this because I'm cleaning up two of these. There's no questioning and you share with them an incredible amount of like for the more

00:11:29higher end clubs, you share a whole lot of information ranging from like your food preferences to your tennis preferences, to your kids names, to your bank accounts, to your wealth, to your assets.

00:11:44If you go on vacation through the country club, like it's, it's, it's astounding to me. And to mark to your point, Daniel, your point, a little bit of elbow grease and effort probably would go a long way to help them in managing that risk and understanding the risk.

00:11:59But at least the country clubs, I mean, I'm not very active in the country club scene, but in the two that I've been involved with cleaning up, right?

00:12:08It doesn't appear that the members ask a whole lot of diligence over how do they actually protect the information they're giving. Everybody wants to join the country club. So nobody's really asking any, any substantive questions about security controls when they're submitting all of their information, which is kind of crazy.

00:12:26But I mean, at least for the ones I'm dealing with, they like, they collect their full financials. There's like a financial worksheet that was supplied and provided.

00:12:35Well, I think there's a disconnect, right? Because there's an expectation on the customer side that if you're handing over that information, that the club is going to protect it.

00:12:45And the club may not necessarily have focused on, okay, I have all this information. What is my, that information is a liability.

00:12:57And right, because it's the, there's the potential for a data breach associated with that information. So it's thinking about that information as a liability and trying to decide do I really want this information around after I've processed, you know, the application and made a decision.

00:13:16Do I want their credit card number around? Yeah, that could be helpful to, you know, to, to, to charge stuff in the future.

00:13:25But do I want their tax returns around? Probably not. I probably want to destroy that.

00:13:30I didn't even realize, Mark, that you submit your tax returns to join a country club. It's only in the breach I'm dealing with or mediating. Did I realize that people actually, they don't turn in their full tax return. Sorry, somewhat of a tangent, but they provide like pieces of their tax returns to justify like joining the club, I guess.

00:13:54I mean, go ahead, Dan. I'm sorry. Well, like personally, I don't belong to a country club. Okay. But I belong to a tennis club that I belong to for years that anybody can join.

00:14:05And it's not even in the amount of information now that they have returned between credit card information, personal information, my kids information and to take tennis lessons, you know, all that stuff like that.

00:14:16And it's all now on a web, you know, on an online and a cloud based dashboard that let alone if I was applying for, like Daniel was just discussing before, like a high end membership somewhere, particularly when you're talking about, like I said before, these residential slash club type of setups where, you know, there may be a financial lending even arrangement between the two that you're, you know, buying into.

00:14:46A piece of ownership, so they want to be able to do a credit check on you. So they have that sensitive information.

Automatically generated; it may contain errors.

Lesson notes

Explains why private clubs are attractive targets, including their casual operating environment and integration with payment and member systems, with recent club breaches as examples.

Study materials

Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.

Study notes

Data breaches are now a common occurrence

Data breaches are no longer the exception. The global average cost of a data breach cited in the lesson was 4.88 million dollars, and the U.S. leads other countries in breach cost. For any organization, the question is less whether a breach will happen than when.

Why private clubs are attractive targets

Clubs are not the traditional victims organizations think of, but several features make them targets:

  • Casual operating environments. Unlike medical practices, law firms, accounting firms or banks, which constantly think about two-factor authentication and redaction, clubs and other social organizations blend daily operations with social activity, in person and online.
  • Holes in the fence. Published member directories, promoted events and social media make it easy to learn sensitive information about people.
  • Low-hanging fruit. Attackers go after the easiest point of entry. Law firms once played that role; clubs, with lots of data and modest defenses, now do.
  • Limited budgets. Members may not want higher dues to fund cybersecurity, so club security likely lags behind banks, law firms and medical practices.
  • Changing volunteer boards. Clubs are often run by elected boards whose members change every few years and may not be educated on cyber risk. An outgoing board may raise the issue, only for the next board to weigh an assessment against spending on a new facility or tennis court.

A 2017 National Club Association survey found that 41% of member clubs had conducted a cybersecurity vulnerability assessment in the prior year, a sign the issue was only beginning to be addressed. Clubs have been hit: the lesson cited two 2024 attacks on California clubs in which attackers compromised and exfiltrated member data.

What member data clubs hold

Clubs often hold a treasure trove of information:

  • Application materials, sometimes including asset checks, financial worksheets and portions of tax returns for exclusive clubs.
  • Credit card information, and for clubs tied to residential developments, credit checks and financial information used to assess ability to pay dues and assessments.
  • Children's names and activities, food and tennis preferences, travel booked through the club, and other personal details.

Documents are often scanned or stored as PDFs on a server or a cloud platform that may not be particularly secure, and many clubs lack document management and data destruction protocols. Poor data governance creates further problems: one club had to notify the families of deceased members whose data it still held. Many clubs also lack cyber insurance.

Treating member data as a liability

Members rarely ask how a club will protect the extensive information they hand over; everyone wants to join. There is a disconnect: members expect the club to protect their data, while the club may not have recognized that the information is a liability. After processing an application, a club should ask whether it needs to keep each item. A card number may be useful for future charges, but tax returns probably should be destroyed.

Low-cost first steps: vendor risk allocation and basic readiness

Meaningful protection does not have to be expensive:

  • Allocate risk to vendors. Where a third party hosts the website or manages member data, a phone call and contract terms can require the vendor to carry insurance and bear the costs of a breach it causes. Most clubs do not have this in place.
  • Assess and plan. Conduct a vulnerability assessment and adopt an incident response plan, the basic blocking and tackling that gets the club's house in order.
  • Educate the board. Those approving the budget need information about the threat to weigh it against other spending.

Notifying members after a breach is an awkward process, and preparation makes it far more manageable.

Flashcards

12 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.

Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.

1 of 12

Practice quiz

Practice — not graded, not the final exam

Question 1 of 5Why might a private club be more vulnerable to attack than a law firm or bank?
Choose an answer to check it.