Cyber Insurance and the Incident Response Plan
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Sign in to take the examPass it for a verifiable Certificate of CompletionThen
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:00:00Identifying and ensuring that as this as the crown jewels. So, I want to talk about, well, really, very, I think cyber insurance is maybe not ensuring cyber insurance.
00:00:20Daniel, the ability or the benefit of having insurance for a club that goes beyond just property insurance and is specific for cyber insurance. Can you just talk about how that's beneficial and can minimize the cybersecurity risk?
00:00:38Yeah, so insurance helps you when you apply for insurance, you have to get your house in order. So good first step, apply for insurance, which usually requires you to do something with cybersecurity.
00:00:49And then in the process of getting insurance, your carrier usually will have additional services or your broker that can help you figure that out. But I think at a practical level, walking through that, understanding what the policy covers and doesn't cover,
00:01:04and understanding the interplay of your DNO coverage as well as your property, understanding how all your different coverages work together as well as really important.
00:01:14Country clubs are this unique quasi organization, right? Because of the way they're set up, they can be, you know, have a whole lot of personal information of young kids.
00:01:28A lot more than a lot of organizations as well as adult as well as payment information and make sure that your insurance coverage policy covers you for all of the different types of data that are going to be there for notification and other pieces because the law is, you know, for minors and other things can be more complicated, I guess.
00:01:48Yeah, I would say it's not just about purchasing cyber insurance because what has happened is different aspects of cyber attacks end up being covered under different policies.
00:02:08And so it's a little bit about having someone take a look at all of your policies to make sure there aren't gaps between the policies and that you think you've bought coverage when in fact you really haven't.
00:02:26And part of these can be covered under property policies. If there's sort of physical damage to the computers as a result of the attack, part of it can be covered under a crime policy, which can be its own policy where if you have an insider that has committed a crime
00:02:54that you can get coverage there, part of it can be covered under cyber insurance policy. And so it's about having someone knowledgeable really look at the various different aspects of potential cyber attacks to make sure that you're covered across the board.
00:03:10I think we've discussed a little bit, but the importance of having an incident response plan that is implemented and practiced upon. Dan, why is this such a key point in mitigating risk for cyber security for clubs?
00:03:34Well, I think it touched upon a little bit earlier having a standard operating procedure that's honored in practice. It helps on a number of levels. Most importantly, it keeps people alert. It keeps things consistent. When things are consistent, usually risk is typically mitigated, provided that what's being consistent is something that is a good decision in the first place.
00:04:02It also helps, I think, with respect to claims, because if you're not adhering to a set of policies and protocols, God forbid there is a breach and you're looking to have the coverage under insurance policy, they're going to say, well, were you sticking to the plan?
00:04:27Mark, in your experience with consulting, do you find that many of your clients are focusing on adherence to their incident plan? Are they in their infancy of even developing one?
00:04:45Not really. I find that you have the plan and then the attack comes and the shit hits the fan and folks are doing what they're doing. The value to me in the plan is not necessarily that it's a playbook that you roll out after an attack.
00:05:12It's really the process of writing the plan and implementing the plan that forces people to think through things like, okay, who is the decision maker going to be in the event of an attack?
00:05:28Who are we going to call? Who do we have on speed dial in the event of an attack? It's the process of putting together the incident response plan, I think, that is frankly more useful than just having a generic or off-the-shelf plan that you stick in a file somewhere
00:05:54and then you pull out in case of an attack.
00:05:59I think also the important part for the incident plan is, and, Mark, you mentioned it, is that you want to bring in the different sectors, right? You want to bring in HR, you want to bring in membership director, you want to know all the stakeholders, what their responsibilities are and have those clear lines of communication and responsibilities well before any incident does occur.
00:06:29And then with the information that we've talked about, then educating and testing upon, run that cyber audit, run that tabletop, and then that's why you're going to test your plan, making sure that the stakeholders are there to see if there are any gaps within the plan or any revisions that are needed.
00:06:52Sure. So to think about that, let's just take a ransomware attack and you're trying to decide whether to pay the ransom or not. That's a really difficult question and you can have a plan that starts to go through permutations as to when we would or would not pay it.
00:07:11But if you actually think about it in advance, then you should never be in that situation at all. How do you avoid that situation? You have another copy of all of your data housed off-site and then all of a sudden the potency of the ransomware attack is substantially mitigated.
00:07:32And it's all about thinking about it in advance and buying insurance, having your data, another copy of your data. If you think about it in advance, you may never be in that box, that incident response box in the first place.
00:07:49Yeah, country clubs are really interesting because they're very sensitive about even, even if they have a backup of all their data, they may.
00:07:58It's a very interesting conversation among the board members with regards to country clubs and paying ransom or not. Sometimes paying the ransom just to know that they deleted it, even if you can get back up and running is something given the dynamics at country clubs is something they.
00:08:15Whether I agree with it in the appropriate course of action or not is it, is it just, I do agree with you Mark wholeheartedly that having that conversation is the appropriate course at least you know which way you're going to go.
00:08:28In the interest of time, I want to stress upon the testing regularly. We keep mentioning it, but here on the slide just has various ways,
00:08:40key points that should be thought about during the testing phase, right? Third party testing, disclosing the results to the board and hiring cyber threat intelligence.
00:08:53Daniel, with your expertise and, you know, your experience being a third party to test the, all these things, what value does going outside of the country club bring to testing?
00:09:08Well, we don't have any bone in the fight. So I mean, we're, we give unvarnished truth, which isn't always so well received. And at least in our, in our situation, we don't also remediate.
00:09:20So all I do, all we do is come in, assess, evaluate, tell you all the problems, and then I want to say drop the mic, but we then refer you to other people to get it all fixed and working and then we'll come back and check again.
00:09:33Like, we're not trying to upsell or anything else, and we're really there just to help secure and mitigate and manage the risk, right? We're not there to tell you to put endpoint protection in which one to buy or deploy or whatever else.
00:09:45We'll be like, you need endpoint protection deployed, right? And then we'll tell your IT people to figure out which one's appropriate and we'll come back the next year and we'll look and see if you have it deployed.
00:09:55But we're not, you know, because it's a, it's a balancing act, right? We don't want to make money off our recommendations and what we suggest, right? And we say get training, right?
00:10:06And so we'll say buy a training package. Here's four of them. Pick whichever one you want, right? And we'll come back and check to see if the training's been implemented.
00:10:14We'll say buy cybersecurity insurance, but we will, and we'll introduce you to some brokers, but we're not going to put ourselves in the middle of the conversation.
00:10:22We'll say reevaluate all your contracts because your contracts aren't properly teed up. And when we audit it, you know, X, Y, and Z and add these, you know, consider adding these clauses, but hire your own lawyers to make sure the language is appropriate, right?
00:10:36So we do it independently to look at how to manage that risk and then let other people sort of deliver that solution.
00:10:42So we're not conflicted out of trying to upsell or anything else. We're just there to do the audit and go.
00:10:51One point on that is some of the cyber insurers are moving to have their customers, so the insured, apply some premiums or apply some dollars towards doing incident response, towards increasing the cybersecurity.
00:11:16And, you know, most folks are spending the money. Go ahead.
00:11:20No, no, Mark, you're 100% right. So I forgot to say some underwriters will take some of their premium, disk to premium that will be paid and will apply that to us doing the audit.
00:11:30So in fairness to what Mark's saying, though, like we work with a couple underwriters where for a certain size or whatever, they'll take some of the actual money where they'll provide a credit to offset some of the cost of the audit itself.
00:11:45Because frankly, the underwriter doesn't want to ensure a bad risk. I mean, that's the takeaway from the carrier's perspective.
00:11:53I mean, that's what they're really they don't want to end up insuring someone that doesn't have two F.A. turned on, right?
00:11:59Or they, you know, or they have, you know, like, so that's why they're funding it.
00:12:04Like driver's ed.
00:12:05Yeah. Yeah, exactly. A little more expensive, but same idea.
00:12:11Right.
00:12:12Well, wonderful. I want to thank you all for participating in today's webinar. We run up against time and I thank you for sharing your insights. They were incredibly valuable.
00:12:24I feel like someone's going to listen to.
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Lesson notes
Covers how cyber insurance helps a club, how to understand what a policy covers alongside D&O and property coverage, and how to plan for ransomware demands with off-site data copies and an incident response plan.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
How applying for cyber insurance improves a club's security
Cyber insurance helps before any claim. Applying for coverage usually requires the club to do some cybersecurity work, so the application is a good first step toward getting the club's house in order. Carriers and brokers often offer additional services to help.
Some underwriters go further, applying a portion of the premium, or providing a credit, toward an independent cybersecurity audit for insureds of a certain size. The insurer's motive is simple: it does not want to insure a bad risk, such as an organization without two-factor authentication turned on. One analogy is driver's education, a little more expensive, but the same idea.
Looking across all policies for gaps in coverage
Buying a cyber policy is not enough, because different aspects of an attack may be covered under different policies:
- Property policies may cover physical damage to computers caused by an attack.
- Crime policies may cover losses where an insider committed a crime.
- Cyber policies cover other aspects of an incident.
- Directors and officers coverage interacts with all of these.
Someone knowledgeable should review all of the club's policies together to find gaps, so the club does not believe it bought coverage it lacks. Clubs are unusual organizations: they hold a large amount of personal information about young children as well as adults, plus payment information, and the law on notification involving minors can be more complicated. Coverage should reach every type of data the club holds.
Why the incident response plan must be practiced, not filed away
A standard operating procedure honored in practice keeps people alert and consistent, which reduces risk if the procedure is sound. It also matters for claims: after a breach, an insurer will ask whether the club followed its own plan.
In reality, when an attack hits, people often do whatever they do, regardless of the plan. The greatest value lies in the process of writing and implementing the plan, which forces decisions in advance: who will make decisions during an attack, whom to call, and who is on speed dial. A generic, off-the-shelf plan sitting in a file adds little.
The planning process should include all stakeholders, such as HR and the membership director, with clear responsibilities and lines of communication established well before an incident. Then educate, run a cyber audit and a tabletop, and test the plan to find gaps and needed revisions.
Avoiding the ransomware decision through off-site backups
Deciding whether to pay a ransom is very difficult, and a plan can work through when the club would or would not pay. Better still is to avoid the situation: keep another copy of all data housed off-site, which substantially reduces the potency of a ransomware attack. Thinking ahead, buying insurance and maintaining backups may keep a club out of that box entirely.
Clubs have their own dynamics. Even with backups, some boards consider paying a ransom just for assurance that stolen data will be deleted. Whatever the board decides, it should have that conversation in advance so it knows which way it will go.
Independent testing and avoiding conflicts of interest
Regular testing should include third-party testing, disclosure of results to the board and, where appropriate, cyber threat intelligence. An outside tester has no stake in the outcome and can give the unvarnished truth.
Independence means separating assessment from remediation. An independent assessor evaluates, reports the problems and refers the club elsewhere for fixes, then returns to check. It might say endpoint protection, training or insurance is needed, or that contracts need new clauses, but leaves product choices to the club's IT team, the purchase of training to the club, and the drafting to the club's own lawyers, so the assessor is not conflicted by upselling its own recommendations.
Flashcards
12 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 12
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam