Legal Cyber Academy

What a Breach Costs a Club: Member Data, Notification, and Training

Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.

Up next

Tabletop Exercises, Vendors, and Basic Controls
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.

00:00:00The consequences for country clubs that don't have, you know, best practices in cybersecurity are strong.

00:00:07You know, financial loss, reputational damage, loss of trust, legal ramifications.

00:00:13Mark, where do you see the most impact with these consequences for country clubs?

00:00:22Well, in terms of the I would think, I mean, Daniel may be more focused on this right now to see where these folks are getting it hardest, but it seems to me that the reputational

00:00:39is probably the most consequential. I mean, if you're, if you're entrusting as a consumer, you're entrusting your information to the club and the club gets hacked and let's say the club doesn't necessarily isn't quick enough to inform people about this and folks have, you know,

00:01:05their information in the hands of the fraudsters who then file an application for a tax refund in the person's name or some credit card charges or they get access to their kids names or medical information.

00:01:29You know, that's potentially a real reputational hit that that club takes where they lose the confidence of their, of their membership.

00:01:41So that's if they even notify their membership.

00:01:47What about the regulatory implication?

00:01:50So this is where it gets really crazy. There's actually in certain states, like, so if you have, if you're a fairly large tennis club, Daniel, I'm sure that if there's a breach, they have more than 500 members, they have to report it to the Massachusetts AG and all these other people and all these other things that play in.

00:02:09And then so it's kind of crazy when you think about it. And I don't actually belong to a country club as well, but

00:02:20it's just when you look at it and you just think about it. And the more I think, the more I thought about it as I've gone through it, right? No members ever asked them for their security controls.

00:02:31Nobody has ever applied, has ever asked. Nobody said, how do you actually protect my information? How do you dispose of it when you're done with my application process?

00:02:41How do you, you know, if I, if I don't play tennis at your tennis club for three years, do you purge me from the system, right? Because what turns out happening, just FYI, is that you have so much information on these people that it actually can be used fairly nefariously to cause harm.

00:02:57And, and then do you notify them? How do you notify them and all these things that come into play? So I don't know, Jennifer, I touched on all of the things you wanted, but.

00:03:09This slide just really talks about the different various attack vectors. I want to highlight phishing because we've talked a lot about members, but phishing with country club employees.

00:03:21Right. And that goes towards the education, educating your employees about what a phishing scam looks like. If there is, you know, someone opens an email from a trusted vendor and all of a sudden there's a hyperlink that redirects, right? There's many insights that we've talked about that insider threat, how they're going to get into your system. Anything to add? Mark or Dan?

00:03:51It seems to me that you touched on the education. There are lots of different ways in. And with some forethought and some education, a hell of a lot of those can be not necessarily eliminated, but the chances of it happening being reduced substantially with a fairly limited effort in terms of educating folks.

00:04:21Right. In terms of not falling for the phishing and in terms of not using the same password on that system that folks are using, whether it's employees or clientele, not using the same password to access that system as they use to access other systems.

00:04:47Yeah, it's low hanging fruit. The problem is that country clubs haven't done what everybody else has done, which is basic training. Like, do you have spear phishing training for the people that work at the front desk? Do you have just the basics, right? And going through that and creating that sort of process and program, in part because the way a country club is structured, the people at the front desk rotate through fairly frequently.

00:05:15And so, you know, they have generic accounts. How do you train them? How do you manage these processes? And so I think at a practical level, I do agree with you, Mark. I just think that, you know, given the way they're structured, you just have to think about it. I mean, I know, Daniel, how many different kids have worked at the front desk at the tennis club in the past three years?

00:05:33Yeah, I mean, I think also, right. I mean, you know, there's, there's, you're used to, in country clubs, I remember, like, my grandparents belong to one, right? In New York. I remember that, like, they have, like, a number, a membership number, but then they would get a bill probably at some point in time.

00:05:54I belong to the Harvard Club. You're right. You get a bill. You get, you get, like, you got a member card and they give you, like, and they, you're right.

00:06:02And they get a bill. But, but now, you know, that member number that a lot of times is still, you know, being mentioned out loud somewhere, it goes into some POS system, let's say at a restaurant, that's then connected on the back end to a credit card that's connected to your, you know, profile within the club system.

00:06:26You know, so it's, it's, it almost, this sort of exclusivity of the situation of the environment that's supposed to be presumably more exclusive. When it comes to your data, it ends up being even more vulnerable.

00:06:41Right. Actually, I know of a club that on their golf cart has that member number, and you use that when you want to purchase anything, but it's on your golf cart. So you drive around, anyone sees it.

00:06:52And with that number, you can give it to anyone and access it. It's actually then their pin numbers to get into their portal, their club portal.

00:07:03Right. Okay. Yeah.

00:07:07So, I want to talk about the strategies we've discussed really the issues the potential, you know, vulnerability that country clubs have.

00:07:15But let's talk about best practices and trying to manage that that cyber risk.

00:07:21I think the importance of developing the strong cybersecurity posture, their cyber hygiene. On this screen there's a few various ways to improve upon that.

00:07:35Do you want to touch about anyone that you find particularly interesting?

00:07:41In, in terms of on the slide in terms of this particular bullet point. Well, yeah, I think the, the first one, let's take the first one. So the robust passwords Mark touched upon that before two factor authentication.

00:07:59I think the, I think having a standard protocol for in committing to a specific platform that that protocol can apply to.

00:08:12So if it's a certain type of file sharing program that, you know, that the organization picks, you know, one or two that they're using depending on the department and depending on what the needs are and the features.

00:08:25And they become very knowledgeable on that specific platform.

00:08:29And that there's also in that when if there's two factor authentication, people aren't putting in, you know, personal cell phone numbers to have their, you know, to have that.

00:08:44But what is two factor authentication in case anyone isn't familiar?

00:08:48Well, as I understand it, or as I experienced it all on a day to day basis is is that you're putting it's a second layer of credentials to ensure that the person is trying to access the platform to get to the data is the person that in fact is supposed to be having access under that particular profile.

00:09:10So if you put in your email and log in, a lot of times it'll, you know, a lot of depending on the platform or then prompt to maybe send a code to that email also so that it's ideas is that if you're getting access to your email with that code and put that code in that you're the person that's supposed to be accessing that information.

00:09:31The only thing that can be problematic about doing it that way is is that if you don't have a secure email system and depending on particularly I know we're talking about country clubs, but other sectors that could be that may not even be enough in and of itself.

00:09:43You may have to, you know, do, you know, like, for example, you know, authentication applications, right?

00:09:54Daniel, what would be a reasonable way for training the employees? And I know it says proper email etiquette, but I think I want it.

00:10:03Don't let them email.

00:10:07I think, you know, the best sort of training is, you know,

00:10:13like simulate a cyber incident, have them actually experience and sit through it, whether you send them a spear phishing email and they click on it.

00:10:20But really, what is it like it's at a practical level, but like it's the small things.

00:10:26It's like if there's a cyber incident, the country club, the members are going to call the front desk.

00:10:33Do you have a like, so you're going to have to train the front desk people on what to do and how to respond, right?

Automatically generated; it may contain errors.

Lesson notes

Covers what a breach can cost a club, including reputational damage, state notification and regulatory obligations, and staff training such as simulated incidents.

Study materials

Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.

Study notes

What a breach costs a club: reputation, trust and regulators

The consequences for clubs without good cybersecurity practices include financial loss, reputational damage, loss of trust and legal ramifications. Reputation may be the most consequential. Members entrust their information to the club. If the club is hacked, and especially if it is slow to tell members, fraudsters may use that information to file tax refund claims in members' names, run up card charges, or access children's names or medical information. The club can lose its membership's confidence, and that assumes it notifies members at all.

Regulatory obligations add to the burden. Depending on the state and the number of people affected, a club may have to report a breach to the state attorney general and other authorities in addition to notifying members.

Questions members never ask about their data

Members almost never ask how a club protects their information:

  • How is my information protected?
  • How is it disposed of after the application process?
  • If I stop using the club for years, am I purged from the system?
  • If there is a breach, how will I be notified?

Because clubs collect so much information, it can be used nefariously to cause real harm, which makes these questions worth asking and answering.

How attackers get in: phishing employees and exposed member numbers

Attack vectors are many, but phishing aimed at club employees deserves particular attention. An email that appears to come from a trusted vendor can contain a link that redirects to a malicious site. With some forethought and education, the chances of these attacks succeeding can be reduced substantially with fairly limited effort, both by teaching people to recognize phishing and by discouraging password reuse across systems, for employees and members alike.

Clubs have often not done the basic training others have: for example, spear-phishing training for front desk staff. Club structure makes this harder. Front desk staff rotate frequently, often use generic shared accounts, and may be young seasonal workers, so training must be built into the club's processes.

Club traditions can also create exposure. Members are often identified by a membership number that may be spoken aloud, entered into restaurant point-of-sale systems and linked on the back end to a credit card and member profile. One club displayed member numbers on golf carts; the number could be used to make purchases and also served as the PIN for the member portal. The exclusivity of the environment can make member data more vulnerable, not less.

Strengthening cyber hygiene: passwords, platforms and two-factor authentication

Best practices for a stronger cybersecurity posture include:

  • Robust passwords and two-factor authentication for systems that hold member data.
  • Standard platforms and protocols. Commit to one or two file-sharing or management platforms, chosen by department need, and become knowledgeable about them, rather than letting tools proliferate.
  • Proper two-factor setup. Two-factor authentication adds a second layer of credentials, such as a code sent to a registered email, to confirm the person logging in is the authorized user. Staff should not tie club accounts to personal cell phones, and if the email system itself is not secure, an authentication application may be needed.

Training staff through simulated incidents

Effective training is practical. Simulate a cyber incident and have employees experience it, for example by sending a test spear-phishing email and seeing who clicks. Training should also cover the small things that matter during a real event: when a breach occurs, members will call the front desk, so front desk staff need to know what to say and how to respond.

Flashcards

11 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.

Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.

1 of 11

Practice quiz

Practice — not graded, not the final exam

Question 1 of 5A club is breached and waits weeks before telling members, while fraudsters use the data. Which consequence did the panel see as most serious?
Choose an answer to check it.