Ledger models and dispute types across different digital assets
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Preserving, collecting, and authenticating blockchain evidence in practiceTranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:00:00Yeah, I think those are all excellent points.
00:00:06So not all ledgers produce the same record. I'm just going to touch on this really quickly and then jump us forward a slide or two just to keep us on time.
00:00:14But basically, this is a shocker to lawyers, but not everything is the same. Just because it's on the blockchain doesn't mean it's the same as the other thing on the blockchain.
00:00:24And I really find that, you know, you have to understand these concepts of public permission list permission, UTXL model and account model and understand the differences.
00:00:35We don't really, you know, this probably could be a whole separate technical class in its own right.
00:00:40But you can see public permission lists are sort of Bitcoin and ETH, which most people know about.
00:00:46Anybody can read and write. History is available to any party, no gatekeeper to subpoena.
00:00:53No one to authenticate permission. Its access is controlled by an operator.
00:00:58One custodian, well, there's a custodian who makes the 9021.
00:01:03And as Judge pointed out, these other things, 90213, a lot more workable.
00:01:10Then you have the UTXL model where its value tracked is discrete unspent unit outputs.
00:01:20Coin level tracing can be done. It's a little different.
00:01:24And then you have the last account model where balances are held at addresses.
00:01:31The contract state, so meaning what's the state of the smart contract at the address is sometimes as important as what's actually moving in and out.
00:01:41And then tracing logs certainly differ materially.
00:01:45But I was hoping maybe we could go through the digital asset types and disputes they generate just at a high level.
00:01:51Maybe Angus run through this, then Judge and then Justin weigh in, I know.
00:01:55Angus, you see a lot of these sort of different disputes.
00:02:02Yeah, I think our experience is generally being representing exchanges or people who have lost their crypto to hacks.
00:02:10And it's really interesting to see that there's almost always a civil and criminal component to this.
00:02:19There's always some nefariousness involved, even if your client is just trying to run a legitimate business,
00:02:29for example, an exchange or a wallet or a deposit intermediary.
00:02:35They're always being used by somebody trying to perpetrate a crime.
00:02:40And so it's very interesting to try to navigate those issues.
00:02:45And that's one aspect I see a lot.
00:02:48And another aspect is that there's a massive international retail component to a lot of these disputes.
00:02:56Retail investors and really, I guess, retail gamblers love crypto.
00:03:03And when you have kind of unsophisticated investors, investors, gamblers slash involved,
00:03:14you get a lot of kind of civil fraud types of disputes that basically arise out of volatility and nothing else.
00:03:27Yeah. Justin?
00:03:29Yeah, I think that is right.
00:03:33I guess my experience has been similar to Angus, right?
00:03:36A lot of the disputes where these issues have arisen, where we've seen it, have involved crypto being stolen.
00:03:45And that often happens in a way that doesn't implicate a blockchain in any sort of direct way, or not in a way that's particularly in dispute.
00:03:56But I have seen some of these, for some of these issues like where the question is, who has the authority to authorize a digital asset movement?
00:04:08One of the issues that I've seen arise several times where sort of blockchain or permissioning structure can become relevant is where there's some sort of contractual agreement about who has the right to do what,
00:04:19but it doesn't align who has the permission to actually control the crypto from a technical standpoint.
00:04:25So you may have a contract, for instance, that says this can't happen, only one party can execute a certain move, but the blockchain is actually, the ability to do that on the blockchain doesn't align with that perfectly,
00:04:40like other parties would have the power to do it as well.
00:04:43And then the questions, you can get several questions that arise from that.
00:04:47First of all, you may need evidence of what the blockchain actually allows to show that a transaction was or was not in accordance with what you'd agreed to, or what the contract said.
00:04:58And then secondly, the question can arise, well, if the blockchain structure or rules itself, a aspect of the agreement, so if it allowed it, does it have some sort of legal force if you built together or entered into together
00:05:15into some kind of decentralized asset that had a blockchain behind it?
00:05:20And how that plays out can really vary. That can be very fact specific, particularly when you have permission to blockchains that are being built for specific purposes, not general purposes crypto like Bitcoin.
00:05:32You often need to get into the specific details of who had the ability to execute certain transactions and who did.
00:05:40Yeah, and I would say I don't have much to add other than, again, those kind of ground level probate family law type cases.
00:05:55And I think the tension there is really, they're a lot more like criminal cases in the sense that you're trying to get that attribution, that gumshoe type evidence of where was this asset hidden?
00:06:09Where was it? The money that was taken from the regular investment account and then put into some type of other investment, but it's done without the resources, right?
00:06:23You have sole practitioners who don't have investigative teams or who don't have sophistication when it comes to this, trying to do these types of tracing and really relying on forensic accountants and things like that.
00:06:36So I would say that that's again, where I see a lot of lower value cases are going to come to the forefront, but are going to be super prevalent because it's going to be ubiquitous in probate matrimonial litigation, things like that.
00:06:55Well, that's a great summary. I'm just going to, so the attribution gap, I think we were just talking about Angus, you've alluded to it, but there's basically is, you know, well, maybe I'll let Justin, you speak to this and then Angus and then judge, you can follow on and we'll keep it moving.
00:07:20Yeah, we didn't touch on it earlier, but I think this is key and probably one of the areas that I got the most experience with as a prosecutor because these cyber crimes are generally whodunits type of cases.
00:07:33And the evidence, like I said, there is a technical aspect to it, right, in terms of the blockchain tracing.
00:07:44Usually that part of it, from an investigative standpoint, from a building a case standpoint, from an advocacy standpoint, is not necessarily the hard part of it.
00:07:53It's the connection of an actual person or company to a specific address or a specific transaction.
00:07:59And a lot of times the evidence for that looks almost old fashioned, right?
00:08:04Do they have messages of people where they say, yeah, that's mine.
00:08:09Is it, are the assets being used for their benefit to buy their cars or their, you know, their gold watches?
00:08:16Okay, that's probably not going to come up in your civil cases.
00:08:19Maybe it will. That's more of a criminal case thing.
00:08:21But, you know, is it being used to fund their operations?
00:08:26Is it, as it moves both on the blockchain and off the blockchain, are the assets commingled with assets controlled by a person or a company?
00:08:35All these are like, you know, common sense evidence that an advocate could use to argue that, okay, these are the ways that we know this address is actually controlled by this person or this company.
00:08:46And it is, in that sense, once you get to the block training part, more similar to like how you tie any unattributed funds or wire transfer or bank count under a fake name to a particular person.
00:09:02And so I think a lot of these cases, the work as an advocate is where there's a blockchain analysis and an attribution question, whether it's civil or criminal.
00:09:13A lot of the advocacy work goes into building that part of the case, right?
00:09:17And that should look familiar to you, even if this is your first time dealing with blockchain issues.
00:09:23Like, how do you show that it actually belonged to this person is the real question.
00:09:30I guess anything you want to add?
00:09:32Yeah, it's just it's not a, it's different from almost traditional cases where the attribution is like it's reversed, right? The attribution is very clear.
00:09:44Judge, anything you want to tie back?
00:09:47Just everything that Justin said about criminal cases is kind of true for the matrimonial and probate cases that we see as well, because you're trying to figure out, all right, did that money go into husband's gold watch?
00:09:59Did it go into, you know, did it go into the trustee's gold watch?
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
Ledger models discussed in this lesson
Daniel B. Garrie opens by stressing that not all blockchain records are the same just because they sit "on the blockchain." He identifies several ledger models that lawyers need to distinguish:
- Public permissionless ledgers (examples given: Bitcoin and ETH): anyone can read and write; history is available to any party; there is no gatekeeper to subpoena and no one to authenticate permission.
- Permissioned ledgers: access is controlled by an operator, and there is a custodian who can be the subject of a subpoena (referred to in the transcript as "9021"/"90213"), which Hon. Jackson Lucky notes makes these ledgers a lot more workable for litigation purposes.
- UTXO model: value is tracked as discrete unspent transaction outputs, which allows coin-level tracing.
- Account model: balances are held at addresses, and the state of a smart contract at an address can be as important as what is actually moving in and out. Tracing logs differ materially from the UTXO model.
Daniel B. Garrie notes this distinction could be its own technical class, but the key point for lawyers is that the ledger model in play changes what evidence exists and who can be compelled to produce it.
Civil and criminal overlap in exchange and wallet disputes
Angus F. Ni describes experience representing exchanges, wallets, or deposit intermediaries. In that practice, disputes almost always have both a civil and a criminal component, because even a client running a legitimate business is typically being used by someone else trying to perpetrate a crime.
Angus F. Ni also points to a large international retail component to many crypto disputes. Retail investors and retail gamblers are heavily involved with crypto, and unsophisticated participants generate a significant volume of civil fraud-type disputes that arise largely out of volatility rather than any technical blockchain issue.
When blockchain permissions do not match contractual authority
Justin Herring describes a recurring fact pattern: a contractual agreement specifies who has the right to authorize a digital asset movement, but the technical permissioning on the blockchain does not align with that agreement. For example, a contract may say only one party can execute a move, but on the blockchain other parties may technically have the power to do it as well.
This mismatch raises two evidentiary and legal questions, according to Justin Herring:
- You may need evidence of what the blockchain actually allows, to show whether a transaction was or was not consistent with the contract.
- A legal question arises as to whether the blockchain's own structure or rules should be treated as part of the agreement itself, particularly where parties built or entered into a decentralized asset together.
Justin Herring notes this issue is especially fact-specific with permissioned blockchains built for a particular purpose, as opposed to general-purpose cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, where the details of who had the technical ability to execute a transaction and who actually did so often have to be examined closely.
Probate and matrimonial disputes involving digital assets
Hon. Jackson Lucky describes a category of "ground level" probate and family law cases involving digital assets. These cases resemble criminal cases in that they require attribution-style evidence: tracing where an asset was hidden, and following money moved from a regular investment account into some other asset.
A distinguishing feature, per Hon. Jackson Lucky, is that these cases are often handled by sole practitioners without investigative teams or sophistication in digital asset tracing, who must rely on forensic accountants. Hon. Jackson Lucky expects this category to be a lower-value but highly prevalent source of disputes because digital assets are becoming ubiquitous in probate and matrimonial litigation.
The attribution gap between an address and a person
Justin Herring identifies the "attribution gap" as a central issue, noting that cyber crime cases are typically "whodunit" matters. The technical blockchain tracing is usually not the hardest part; the hard part is connecting an actual person or company to a specific address or transaction.
Evidence used to close that gap is often "old fashioned," according to Justin Herring, including:
- Messages where someone admits an address or asset is theirs.
- Evidence that assets were used for a person's benefit, such as buying cars or other goods (more common in criminal cases).
- Evidence that assets were used to fund a person's or company's operations.
- Evidence that assets moving on and off the blockchain were commingled with assets otherwise controlled by a person or company.
Justin Herring compares this to tying unattributed funds, a wire transfer, or a bank account under a false name to a particular person, and notes that most advocacy work in these disputes, civil or criminal, goes into building this attribution case once blockchain analysis has identified the relevant address or transaction.
Angus F. Ni adds that this situation differs from traditional cases because attribution here is effectively reversed compared to cases where attribution is already clear. Hon. Jackson Lucky ties this back to matrimonial and probate matters, framing the same attribution question as figuring out, for example, whether money went into one spouse's or a trustee's asset.
Flashcards
13 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 13
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam