Why digital asset disputes are becoming a routine part of litigation
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Where courts and tribunals get blockchain evidence wrongTranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:00:00We have a good amount of litigation experience in both tracing and litigation involving crypto.
00:00:08Lucky for me, our panelists are all extremely humble. I've had the privilege of working with most of them and they're all very accomplished in this area with a really proven and solid track record.
00:00:24I don't often say that about most folks.
00:00:29With that said, we'll jump right in. So why do we care now versus any earlier times or whatever? If not, and then fundamentals for the evidentiary record.
00:00:42How do you preserve, collect, and authenticate? We're going to look at tracing attribution and the experts' role, then we're going to talk about discovery and ESI protocol design and arbitration-specific considerations.
00:00:53We have a lot to cover. So why does it matter now?
00:00:57Back when the dinosaurs warmed the earth, this was like a novelty, this whole concept of what we're talking about, digital assets, digital money.
00:01:09And now today it's much more routine on the docket.
00:01:14Maybe Angus, you can sort of speak to it, and then Justin and then Judge Jack, you can weigh in as well in that order, sort of what we're seeing today versus what we did at one point.
00:01:27So I'll turn it over to you guys.
00:01:30Yeah, I mean, I think I've only been representing crypto companies or relating since like 2017. I think by which time this stuff was already kind of hitting the ports in some number, in some kind of good amount.
00:01:46There is this notion amongst practitioners that just because it's crypto, because crypto is all traceable, that you can understand every aspect of what happened on the chain and where the money came from and where it went.
00:02:03And that's just simply not the case. It's everything from tornado cash and other mixers or DEXs that allow people to put crypto in, and then it goes into what happens to it.
00:02:15And then this is anybody's guess. It can get turned into a different crypto, could get wrappers that anonymize it, could go into all kinds of places.
00:02:26And even major cryptocurrency exchanges don't track very well who is using them and how.
00:02:36So I think the tracing aspect of identifying where crypto came from, where it went and who was doing all of it, much more complicated than people generally understand, and it takes a lot more work.
00:02:54And it's not like CSI, Miami. It's not done in 45 minutes. All right, Justin, you're up.
00:03:00Yeah, I think that what has, I think this is a fair description here, right? It's a novelty to routine docket item, and I think in particular, we're probably on the cusp of an explosion in the need to be able to actually introduce evidence related to crypto.
00:03:18I think a lot of litigation that touches upon crypto now, blockchain analysis is not, is not, is an adjunct or is not even necessary if there's not a dispute over who owns it or if the question as to whether or not it was stolen.
00:03:32Like if someone was the item of a fraud and there's litigation, you know, one of these wire frauds or BECs, and there's litigation over who's liable for the loss, which is a common way that this type of issue surfaces.
00:03:45That said, I think this issue is going, this, and you can see that even now in the cases, many of the cases that have made it to court so far, there are criminal cases, the kind of cases that I used to prosecute, right?
00:03:55When you were cybercriminals, we're early adopters of crypto. So by 2015, 2016, the old law enforcement adage, you know, follow the money for a cybercrime prosecutor men, men followed the crypto.
00:04:09But that, those, so not surprising to me that that's where the early case law originated. I do think you're going to get into more complex issues too around ownership.
00:04:18I know we're going to touch on some of those today, but right around when you have an asset with distributed ownership, who's served, if that, if that, if there's alleged wrong, who's, who's actually liable.
00:04:31I mean, just the service issue itself is fairly complex if you have a decentralized ownership structure or at least up in the air.
00:04:38So I think these issues are starting to surface now in the cases that we see even among civil litigants and as crypto explodes, they're going to become like very important because, and it's also interesting to me because they are not necessarily too generous, but each type of digital asset functions like a little bit differently.
00:05:00So it is not necessarily what we can point to common principles is going to be unique issues and as, and as companies, large, small and startup develop digital assets and crypto assets that are, are blockchain based.
00:05:13Each of those comes with its own, own set of questions. So I think this area is going to remain unsettled in that sense for, for a very long time because the novelty of different crypto products is going to keep creating new issues.
00:05:32Jackson judge, you know, you want to have a new.
00:05:45I'd say that the thing we don't want to ignore is crypto is now coming part of what we would think of more pedestrian cases, right?
00:05:54We read about the big criminal prosecutions. We read about, you know, VC type or, or, or organization level disputes.
00:06:04But anybody who can buy crypto can die. And now it becomes appropriate dispute or they can put it into a trust instrument and now it becomes a probate dispute.
00:06:13Any individual who is married, who invests or buys some type of asset like this can get divorced and can try to try to try to hide assets through these vehicles.
00:06:29And so, and the practitioners who are doing that kind of law are generally not in a position unless it's a super high asset case to enlist the help of certain experts or certain law firms that have expertise in these domains.
00:06:46And so I think what we're going to see is not only the types of cases that Justin and Angus have talked about, but, you know, in every divorce, in every probate case, in, in routine, what we would think of as routine business disputes.
00:07:02We're going to have these types of issues and, you know, sole practitioners, small firms with, with very little expertise struggling with authentication and admissibility and discovery of this type of information.
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
Why digital asset disputes are becoming a routine part of litigation
This lesson introduces a panel discussion on digital asset and crypto litigation. The panel plans to cover why these disputes matter now, evidentiary fundamentals (preservation, collection, authentication), tracing and attribution, the role of experts, discovery and ESI protocol design, and arbitration-specific considerations. The notes below cover the opening segment on why digital asset litigation has become routine.
Moving from novelty to a routine docket item
Daniel B. Garrie frames the discussion by noting that digital assets and digital money were once treated as a novelty in litigation. Today, these disputes are much more common on court dockets. The panel is asked to compare what practitioners saw earlier in this area to what they are seeing now.
Why crypto tracing is harder than it looks
Angus F. Ni notes that by around 2017, crypto-related matters were already reaching the courts in meaningful numbers. He pushes back on the common assumption among practitioners that because crypto transactions are recorded, everything about a transaction's origin and destination can be understood.
- Tools such as Tornado Cash, other mixers, and decentralized exchanges (DEXs) allow crypto to be deposited and then become very difficult to follow.
- Crypto can be converted into a different cryptocurrency or passed through wrappers that anonymize it, making its subsequent path uncertain.
- Even major cryptocurrency exchanges do not track well who is using them or how.
- As a result, identifying where crypto came from, where it went, and who was involved is far more complicated than generally understood, and tracing takes substantial work rather than being a quick process.
From criminal cases to a coming expansion of crypto evidence issues
Justin Herring describes the shift from crypto litigation being a novelty to becoming a routine docket item, and suggests the field is approaching a significant increase in the need to introduce crypto-related evidence in court.
- Much litigation touching on crypto does not require blockchain analysis unless there is a dispute over ownership or over whether assets were stolen (for example, disputes over liability following a wire fraud or business email compromise, where parties argue over who bears the loss).
- Many of the earliest cases involving crypto were criminal cases, consistent with cybercriminals being early adopters of crypto; Justin Herring notes that by around 2015-2016, law enforcement following the money for cybercrime prosecutions meant following the crypto.
- Justin Herring expects more complex issues to arise around ownership, including how service of process works when an asset has a distributed or decentralized ownership structure, and who is actually liable when wrongdoing is alleged in that context.
- These issues are already surfacing in civil litigation, and as crypto use grows, they will become increasingly important.
- Each type of digital asset functions somewhat differently, so common principles will not resolve every dispute; unique issues will keep arising as companies of all sizes develop new blockchain-based digital assets. Justin Herring expects the area to remain unsettled for a long time because the novelty of different crypto products will continue generating new issues.
Digital asset disputes reaching ordinary, everyday cases
Hon. Jackson Lucky points out that crypto is becoming part of more pedestrian types of cases, not just high-profile criminal prosecutions or venture-capital and organizational-level disputes.
- Anyone who owns crypto can die, turning it into an appropriate dispute in a probate matter, or can place it into a trust instrument, again raising probate issues.
- Anyone who is married and invests in or buys this type of asset can get divorced, and crypto assets can be used to attempt to hide assets from a spouse.
- Practitioners handling these ordinary matters (divorce, probate, routine business disputes) are generally not in a position to retain specialized experts or law firms with crypto expertise unless the case involves very high asset values.
Practical consequences for sole practitioners and small firms
Hon. Jackson Lucky anticipates that these issues will increasingly appear not only in the large cases Justin Herring and Angus F. Ni described, but also in everyday divorce cases, probate cases, and routine business disputes. Sole practitioners and small firms with little expertise in this area will face difficulty with authentication, admissibility, and discovery of digital asset information in these more ordinary matters.
Flashcards
13 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 13
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam