ESI discovery, spoliation risks, and arbitration strategies for digital assets
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Sign in to take the examPass it for a verifiable Certificate of CompletionThen
- Risky Business: Cryptocurrency, Money Laundering, and Smart ContractsDaniel B. Garrie, Joshua Ashley Klayman and Victor Fang
- Introduction to Utility Tokens and Initial Coin OfferingsDaniel B. Garrie, David A. Cass and 2 others
- Byzantine Generals' Problem: Understanding Crypto and Blockchain TechnologyDaniel B. Garrie, David A. Cass and 2 others
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:00:00So I think there's something to be said for lawyers to really understand the difference of what they're asking for and what's available.
00:00:11You know, basically there was, and who controls it, right? I mean, that's another big issue about who controls custody provider or third party.
00:00:23And I know Angus, you get involved with exchanges a lot, right? And so the question of control often comes up, I'm sure.
00:00:31Maybe you want to speak to some of the records and the links.
00:00:35You know, I have some cryptocurrency trader clients who run their own funds and one of them is obsessive about security and they don't save any kind of private key or stuff that can access their main code wallet anywhere on any electronic device.
00:00:56And it's just, it's pure optioning. He's got it memorized and it's locked up somewhere. So it's, you know, in a litigation, if he doesn't want to be attributed and it doesn't want to disclose what the wallet is, where it is, no one can find out.
00:01:14You know, there's no way to collect the evidence. Only he knows where the key is. And there's absolutely nothing connecting his access of the wallet to, access of the wallet to him in any real world sense.
00:01:27And I have other cryptocurrency, just industry people that I know, not even my clients who, you know, they never pay taxes on cryptocurrency trading.
00:01:40Ever.
00:01:42And this becomes a real interesting issue in matrimonial cases.
00:01:47Yeah. And they only go into, they don't ever go into fiat. They've been trading, you know, for a long, long time. They go, they trade in and out of crypto and to tech or to USDC.
00:01:58And that's how they manage the exchange rate risk and volatility, but they never, never go into fiat. No one can know, you know, how much, they don't even know how much taxes they were supposed to unpaid.
00:02:11Yeah, happens. Justin, and you want to weigh in here on or jump us forward while you're doing it.
00:02:18No, I think I think we've already hit on everything that I would say.
00:02:23Yeah. So one of the things, when you have an ESI dispute and a crypto dispute, please change your protocol.
00:02:31Like I can't, I can't be more direct than that. Someone who is a private judge, hearing discovery disputes.
00:02:38Your ESI protocol must be modified to adjust the blockchain. Here's the list of what you need to think about.
00:02:44I'm not going to read you the list, but you should read it if you're actually going to have an ESI protocol in a blockchain driven related dispute.
00:02:53Because if you don't fix it, you're going to be really upset with the amount of time, money and resources you will expend fighting about these very issues because your protocol doesn't address it.
00:03:05So I want to talk about spoliation and in a self-executing environment, like key destruction, wall of abandonment, self-executing losses.
00:03:16I don't know, maybe Angus, you want to touch on it, the judgment, Justin, sort of what these concepts are.
00:03:25Yeah, this is sort of the thing that I was talking about earlier, right? Once the private key is gone and he doesn't have, you know, someone doesn't have a hot wallet anywhere.
00:03:35That's linked to them. You can, you can truly, like if you, if you go far enough, you can be well and truly anonymous.
00:03:44With your financial transactions, you're just using crypto and there's sometimes there's no way around.
00:03:51Justin, you want to weigh in?
00:03:55You know, it's interesting. I haven't actually addressed with this as a spoliation issue.
00:04:02I usually see it more in the kind of context that I think Angus just talked about where, or where, where a key is lost or, or there's,
00:04:14or there's a claim that a key is lost, right?
00:04:21And I think it's almost like, it's almost like a chicken and egg thing, right? It's like, if you're talking about spoliation, then you, then you've got some attribution already.
00:04:27And, but, but, but, you know, someone who's really intending to spoliate can do it successfully without you ever being able to prove that they did it.
00:04:39Yeah. You can definitely put an asset permanently beyond the reach because it can never be found. You want to know who did it.
00:04:48I mean, at least unless someone testifies saying, which is, which, which generates some interesting things in litigation.
00:04:54Like we have, we represent some wallet clients where they didn't take the money, right?
00:05:02They did not steal the crypto, but the plaintiffs will not believe it. And it's very tough to prove a negative, especially when there's a lot of, there's, you know, if you run a, run a depository and you're using, you know, third parties to manage your, your, your ledger.
00:05:24And those third parties that have these hot wallets where they aggregate all kinds of transactions from other third parties in and they just send you a ledger at the end of the day.
00:05:34So it is so much impossible to explain to a plaintiff, like, no, we didn't take the, we didn't take your crypto and you don't even know what happened to it and nobody else.
00:05:42So that kind of situation is interesting.
00:05:46I don't know if you had to judge anything you want to add. I know we're heading towards the finish line for time, but.
00:05:51I'll make it real quick, but I think this comes back to what Justin's been saying a lot, which is a lot of what you end up proving in these types of disputes as well is just the regular types of evidence that we're dealing with all the time that is independent of blockchain concerns.
00:06:09Yeah, I will tell you, as having heard this, these arguments about wallet abandonment, it's really tricky when someone dies and they have a secret key.
00:06:22I mean, it can really be gone gone if they didn't write it down.
00:06:27And I would say that's the same thing as the legend of grandpa having $3 million in jewels buried in a parking lot in the city of industry, right?
00:06:36It's the same problem in a different wrapper.
00:06:41This makes the problem, in fairness, this does make the problem more common.
00:06:46There are, this can happen with traditional assets, but it's a little more convoluted than it is in the crypto context.
00:06:57I mean, we all know people, right?
00:07:00Well, I know people, more than one person who was like, hey, I'm going to get some Bitcoin in 2012, and then when it exploded in value, you know, and put like a few hundred bucks, and then when it exploded in value years later, I couldn't find the key.
00:07:17You know, it's just, it is, I, yeah, it is not, it is not, well, not a new problem. This makes it so much easier to have, right?
00:07:27Because I would never have it. There's always ways to get access to a bank account that's held by a banking institution if you are, in fact, the real holder of it.
00:07:35But that is not true. Decentralized assets.
00:07:38I mean, I just, I want to make it very clear. You lose it, it's God. Like there's no, if it's like a 25 phrase or 12, 13 phrase code, forget it.
00:07:51Like you would literally, and it, and you know, it's just very tricky. I just think that people trivialize how hard in these things are.
00:07:59I mean, I've had countless cases where guys like a fire came and burned everything down and I have like 3000 ETH and 2600 Bitcoin on a memory stick, but it got melted and we can't.
00:08:16And I'm like, you know, you're like, okay, well, even if we do get off, do you have the password?
00:08:21Cause we can regenerate the wallet from a different source. So like, well, I don't have the password. We're like, well, save yourself some money.
00:08:29Cause we could set up an entire Amazon cloud computing environment and run it for like a hundred years and you won't get it.
00:08:37So I mean, I think it's, you know, it's, it's fairly complicated. Arbitration parties. I've heard my fair share of arbitration disputes.
00:08:49It's, I mean, confidentiality.
00:08:55As long as one party doesn't go off the rails and start posting on like the inventory things where the other party that sees them, the arbitrator certainly doesn't disclose it because they just have to go on to the next thing.
00:09:10But the parties and the litigants sometimes violate that confidentiality.
00:09:15Um, what they give up though is no subpoena over non-party exchanges in most seat. It's, and that is a problem.
00:09:24Okay. That can be a very big problem, depending on what you're trying to achieve in your arbitration.
00:09:30I don't know Angus, Justin, and judge, and then you want to point out from the slide as we head up and show your final thoughts.
00:09:39I, I really like arbitration in a cryptocurrency disputes, but mostly because we were just handling civil disputes and where they're at getting at the money is very important.
00:09:49And I really liked the fact that both California and New York, these big jurisdictions, and even I think Texas and Florida too, maybe have these pro arbitration statutes that say in order to preserve an award and make sure that it's not a blank piece of paper that you can enforce on.
00:10:05You can get an attachment order, uh, upon the commencement of our arbitration. So we use that a lot. Uh, so, uh,
00:10:13very effective. Um, uh, there are, there are various jurisdictional kind of issues that, that, that come up. You know, for example, like if you want to freeze tether and if you can't prove that the counter parties in New York or California or any of these places, what do you do?
00:10:27Um, you know, there's evolving theories about, uh, jurisdiction over people like tether, uh, based on the fact that, for example, they store their collateral at Kendra Fitzgerald in New York.
00:10:38Um, uh, their executives are in and out of New York all the time. So, um, you know, there's these evolving theories on getting a cryptocurrency asset attachment through third party intermediaries.
00:10:49Uh, when the defendant or the counter party is not necessarily in, uh, within the course restriction, but arbitration, I like, uh, primarily because of the attachment powers.
00:11:00Here, Justin, and then judge final comments as we wrap up on the hour.
00:11:05Um, yeah, I'll, I'll just say that I think, you know, we've, one of our themes here has been the authentication and evidence.
00:11:14People are who they, who you say that they are still has many traditional aspects. It's important to remember that we've covered that a lot. I do think also, you know, the bad thing about it too is that, um, we will have a lot of interesting legal issues.
00:11:30And I think to the beginning, it will be like a very long tail on those because in my, as I have encountered these in my work, you get a lot of different types of blockchains that have different types of structures.
00:11:40Right. And so from a, well, the core evidence rules, of course, remain what they are, like how that plays out in particular situations is going to be, um, is going to vary a lot, you know, as, as we try to map these new digital assets onto legal doctrines.
00:11:54I, I think about it as a lot of Fisher foul type, um, type questions, you know, there was this question, which I think has been resolved. It was very hot for years.
00:12:02When is crypto a security, right? Um, for instance, right? Classic, like mapping question. When is it a Fisher? When is it a foul? Like it's not, it's a new type of thing, but we have to try to map it onto like existing documents.
00:12:14I think we'll keep this area very interesting and very active for lawyers like us for quite some time.
00:12:21All right. All right. So judge, we're wrapping up. Final thought. Final comment.
00:12:31Yeah. Just a final thought on arbitration that we hadn't touched on. And that is there are certain jurisdictions that do allow for third party subpoenas in arbitration action.
00:12:42So for instance, the California Arbitration Act. And so if that is a concern for you and you can find a jurisdiction that allows third party discovery in your arbitration and you can find a way for that act to apply to your particular dispute.
00:12:58That may be a way around that, that, uh, that we talked about.
00:13:03And I, and I would agree with that. I hear a bunch of international arbitrations where that is where, depending on where you're seated, there's different authorities.
00:13:11But I thank you all so much for your time. I wish everybody a great rest of their week and I appreciate everybody for taking our time.
00:13:18Please use the contact details.
00:13:19Follow up with anybody if you have any questions and there are way more qualified and accomplished folks here. So you should follow up with them about any of your questions or follow on.
00:13:30So thank you all again for your time and have a great rest of your day. Thank you. Thank you.
00:13:36Bye.
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
Control over private keys and wallet custody in discovery
A recurring discovery issue is figuring out what evidence actually exists and who controls it — the custodian, a provider, or a third party. Angus F. Ni described a cryptocurrency trader client who is extremely security-conscious and never stores a private key or any access information for his main cold wallet on any electronic device; he has it memorized and locked away. In litigation, if that client refuses to disclose the wallet or where the key is, there is no way to collect the evidence and no way to connect his access of the wallet to him in any real-world sense. Only he knows where the key is.
Cryptocurrency tax avoidance and matrimonial case complications
Angus F. Ni also noted industry contacts (not clients) who never pay taxes on cryptocurrency trading because they never convert into fiat currency. They trade crypto in and out of USDT or USDC to manage exchange-rate volatility but never touch fiat. This creates a real problem in matrimonial cases, since no one — including the trader — necessarily knows how much unpaid tax is owed, because the full trading history and value are hard to reconstruct.
Adapting ESI protocols for blockchain-related disputes
Daniel B. Garrie stressed that anyone facing an ESI dispute involving crypto must change their standard ESI protocol. He emphasized that a protocol must be modified to account for blockchain-specific issues, and there is a list of considerations lawyers should read before litigating a blockchain-driven dispute. Failing to fix the protocol in advance leads to significant time, money, and resources spent fighting over issues the protocol never addressed.
Spoliation, key destruction, and wallet abandonment
The panel discussed spoliation risk in a self-executing environment — key destruction, wallet abandonment, and self-executing losses. Angus F. Ni explained that once a private key is gone and there is no linked hot wallet, a person can become truly anonymous with their crypto holdings; there is sometimes no way around this.
Justin Herring said he has not typically treated this as a spoliation issue so much as a situation where a key is lost, or where there is a claim that a key is lost. He described it as a chicken-and-egg problem: discussing spoliation presumes you already have attribution, but someone genuinely intending to spoliate can do so successfully without anyone ever being able to prove it. An asset can be put permanently beyond reach because it can never be found, and proving who did it is extremely difficult absent testimony.
The panel also described wallet clients accused of stealing crypto they did not take, where plaintiffs refuse to believe them. Proving a negative is hard, especially when a depository uses third parties to manage ledgers, and those third parties aggregate transactions from other third parties before sending a daily ledger — making it nearly impossible to show a plaintiff what actually happened to funds.
Hon. Jackson Lucky noted that much of what gets proven in these disputes is still ordinary evidence independent of blockchain-specific concerns. The panel also observed that wallet abandonment is especially tricky when someone dies holding a secret key that was never written down — comparable to a relative supposedly having buried valuables somewhere, just in a different form. The panel added that this problem is not new (people who bought small amounts of Bitcoin years ago and later lost the key), but decentralized assets make the loss far more absolute than a bank account, where a true holder generally has recourse to regain access; losing a 12-, 13-, or 25-word seed phrase for crypto means the funds are gone, with no institutional backstop. Daniel B. Garrie also described cases where clients lost hardware (for example, a memory stick destroyed in a fire) holding large amounts of ETH and Bitcoin, and without the password, no amount of computing power can recover the funds.
Confidentiality and subpoena limits in arbitration of digital asset disputes
Daniel B. Garrie observed that arbitration generally preserves confidentiality, though parties themselves sometimes violate it (for example, by posting information publicly), even though the arbitrator will not disclose it. A significant tradeoff in arbitration is the lack of subpoena power over non-party exchanges in most arbitral seats, which can be a major problem depending on what a party is trying to achieve.
Attachment orders and jurisdictional theories for enforcing arbitration awards
Angus F. Ni said he favors arbitration in cryptocurrency civil disputes largely because jurisdictions such as California, New York, and reportedly Texas and Florida have pro-arbitration statutes allowing a party to obtain an attachment order upon commencement of arbitration, helping ensure an eventual award is enforceable rather than a "blank piece of paper." Jurisdictional issues arise, for example, in trying to freeze assets like Tether when counterparties cannot be shown to be within a given jurisdiction. Evolving theories support jurisdiction over entities like Tether based on facts such as storing collateral with Cantor Fitzgerald in New York and executives regularly traveling in and out of New York, supporting asset attachment through third-party intermediaries even when a counterparty is not clearly within the court's jurisdiction.
Authentication challenges and mapping new digital assets onto existing legal doctrine
Justin Herring reiterated that authentication — confirming people are who they claim to be — still involves many traditional evidentiary principles. He expects a long tail of interesting legal issues because different blockchains have different structures, so while core evidence rules remain constant, how they apply will vary significantly as courts map new digital assets onto existing legal doctrines. He compared this to earlier debates over whether a given crypto asset qualifies as a security, describing it as a recurring challenge of fitting a new type of asset into existing legal categories.
Third-party subpoena availability under state arbitration acts
Hon. Jackson Lucky noted that certain jurisdictions, such as under the California Arbitration Act, allow third-party subpoenas in arbitration. If lack of third-party discovery is a concern, finding a jurisdiction whose arbitration act permits it, and a way to make that act apply to the dispute, may offer a way around the limitation discussed earlier regarding non-party exchange subpoenas.
Flashcards
13 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 13
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam