Legal Cyber Academy

Preserving, collecting, and authenticating blockchain evidence in practice

Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.

Up next

Crypto tracing, attribution evidence, and expert testimony standards
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.

00:00:03That's, that's really what you're trying to do is the same kind of analysis.

00:00:08I mean, truthfully, it's often an interlocking inner intertwined experience between paper and digital and the blockchain and overlaying different records and pieces of evidence.

00:00:20Most companies, and maybe Angus or Justin or Judge, you have different experience, aren't purely digitally blockchain enabled, right?

00:00:28They still have bank ledgers, they still have receipts, they still have credit card expenses and all of these things, right, that you can always allude to and rely on.

00:00:37So it's always, you know, looking at the totality of the picture.

00:00:43This is a case, you should probably, you know, you can read about it.

00:00:46But I mean, where the, I think as I think Judge mentioned the admissibility of blockchain forensics court recognize its validity.

00:00:56And it also looked at some of the other issues like chain analysis and others that were being used to trace the money.

00:01:07I think we can jump right forward.

00:01:10Preservation, collecting and authenticating.

00:01:13So Judge, you want to walk through, this is just one of these things that I find lawyers could really benefit from understanding.

00:01:20Here, this sort of point, we touched on it earlier briefly.

00:01:24Absolutely.

00:01:25And so the, when we look at FRE 901B9, 90213, 90214, first, let's talk about the distinction between the 901s and the 902s, which is 901 puts more of a burden on the proponent of the evidence.

00:01:42902 gives us those self-authenticating mechanisms if we can fit it into one of the categories.

00:01:51And 901B9, when we talk about the authenticity of a process or system, is one of the pathways.

00:01:59What I'd like to point out about 901B9 though, is if we look at 901 before we get to B9, it says these are examples and non-exclusive.

00:02:08And I think that people sometimes fall into the trap of saying, well, I can't find a subsection of 901 that helps me out.

00:02:15That means I can't authenticate.

00:02:17No, that means that you don't have an easier path to authentication where it's mapped out for you.

00:02:23But remember that the standard is, is there sufficient evidence for a try or a fact to find that the thing is what the proponent says that it is.

00:02:34And here are some examples of how you can get there.

00:02:37And so what I would say is look at 901B9 carefully, understand how that section works, have the witness available to do that.

00:02:47Under 902, you may not even need a witness if you can lay the foundation for 13 and 14.

00:02:53And then just remember that if you can't fit it under one of these three, you still have the general principle of 901 to rely on.

00:03:02And remember that the evidence, federal rules of evidence are designed for admissibility and are designed to keep only the lowest quality evidence out,

00:03:12but to allow even poor quality evidence in and let the try or a fact make the determination.

00:03:18I guess anything you want to add?

00:03:21No, this is very helpful, actually.

00:03:25Yeah, I think Jackson makes great points.

00:03:27You know, the rules of authentication are pretty liberal, as Jackson said, right?

00:03:32They're designed for admissibility.

00:03:35And it doesn't have to be technical.

00:03:37You know, the classic one for, like, digital evidence in general is sort of, okay, I've got a digital photograph.

00:03:43You can bring in an expert to testify about the metadata and the photo and how it was taken and the light and the alignment of things.

00:03:48Or you can actually just bring in a witness who says, no, I've seen that building.

00:03:52It looks like that photo.

00:03:54Okay, and that's the authentication, right?

00:03:56That was a very likely evidence.

00:03:59And so you don't have to overcomplicate.

00:04:00I think Jackson is exactly right.

00:04:02You can do it a lot of different ways, including someone's and says, no, I've seen that before.

00:04:05And this and that looks like it looks like what it is or that that can be enough.

00:04:11It just has to be evidence sufficient that that a reasonable try or a fact could conclude that it is what it purports to be.

00:04:18It's not even a preponderance.

00:04:21And there are a lot of paths you can take to get there.

00:04:24I would agree.

00:04:26So collection methodology.

00:04:29So this is something where lawyers really find struggle.

00:04:33They're like, oh, we're going to collect the blockchain or something.

00:04:37And it just doesn't work like that in a practical level.

00:04:42You know, you can download a maybe depending on the type of design, you could download a copy of it.

00:04:48But you have full node block explorer exchange records, wallet imaging, and the state of the smart contract.

00:04:55All of those things can be in play on a single case in a single sort of set of transactions.

00:05:01So I just think it's worth being mindful of that.

00:05:05When you're looking to perform a collection, you understand what you're seeking to do and how you're seeking to do it.

00:05:11I don't know.

00:05:12Maybe there's not.

00:05:14I don't have much more to add to that.

00:05:15I don't know.

00:05:16Justin, Angus, and Judge, if there's anything that you want to add, please feel free.

00:05:21That's from my end.

00:05:29All right.

00:05:32So hashing time stamps at two clocks.

00:05:35So maybe you want to Angus walk through what this is here.

00:05:42Yeah, I guess blockchain time is blockchain time.

00:05:49It's the simplest way to do it.

00:05:51And that's different from where you are at any given time.

00:05:54So there's going to have to be an expert to show up and explain when something happened on the blockchain versus when something happened where you are physically in the world.

00:06:07Fair enough.

00:06:11Judge, anything you want to add to that or Justin?

00:06:16My point would be the kind of footnote at the bottom is that I think people frequently misunderstand hashing that like sometimes they think it's the same thing as some kind of certification that you would get as opposed to no.

00:06:31All it's doing is saying the bits from the source are the same as the bits in the copy.

00:06:37And that's all it is.

00:06:39And so you're going to have to find other ways to prove the other things that you're going to need to do for authenticity.

00:06:50All right.

00:06:51So with that in mind, tracing and attribution.

00:06:53Justin, you want to walk us through this?

00:06:55I know you've had some experience doing this and then Angus and Judge.

00:07:00And I have quite a bit as well, but I'll turn it over to you, Justin.

Automatically generated; it may contain errors.

Study materials

Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.

Study notes

Combining blockchain evidence with traditional financial records

Most companies are not purely blockchain-enabled. They still rely on bank ledgers, receipts, and credit card expenses alongside digital and blockchain records. Building a case typically involves overlaying different records and pieces of evidence rather than relying on blockchain data alone. The analysis looks at the totality of the picture, intertwining paper and digital evidence.

A case was referenced in which a court recognized the admissibility and validity of blockchain forensics, and also considered chain analysis and other methods used to trace money. The transcript does not provide the name or citation of this case.

Authentication under FRE 901 and FRE 902

FRE 901(b)(9), 902(13), and 902(14) are the key authentication provisions for blockchain evidence.

  • FRE 901 places the burden on the proponent of the evidence to authenticate it. Rule 901(b)(9), addressing the authenticity of a process or system, is one pathway under this rule.
  • FRE 902 provides self-authenticating mechanisms. If evidence fits into one of the 902 categories, a witness may not even be needed to lay foundation, as with 902(13) and 902(14).

The examples listed under 901 are non-exclusive. If a specific subsection does not apply, this does not mean the evidence cannot be authenticated. It only means there is no pre-mapped pathway, and the general principle of 901 can still be relied on.

The underlying standard for authentication is whether there is sufficient evidence for a trier of fact to find that the item is what the proponent says it is. This is not a preponderance standard.

The Federal Rules of Evidence are designed to favor admissibility. They are meant to keep out only the lowest quality evidence while allowing even poor quality evidence in, letting the trier of fact weigh it.

Authentication does not require technical proof

Authentication rules are described as liberal and not inherently technical. A commonly cited comparison is a digital photograph: authentication can come from an expert testifying about metadata, lighting, and alignment, or simply from a witness stating that they have seen the building and it matches the photo. Either approach can be sufficient authentication. The standard only requires evidence sufficient for a reasonable trier of fact to conclude the item is what it purports to be.

Collection methodology for blockchain evidence

Lawyers sometimes struggle with how to "collect the blockchain," but there is no single practical method of doing so. Depending on the design involved, collection may include:

  • Downloading a copy of relevant data
  • Using a full node
  • Using a block explorer
  • Obtaining exchange records
  • Wallet imaging
  • Capturing the state of a smart contract

All of these methods can be relevant within a single case or a single set of transactions. It is important to understand what is being sought and how to obtain it before performing a collection.

Hashing, timestamps, and blockchain time versus real-world time

Blockchain time is distinct from the time at any given physical location. An expert is typically needed to explain when something occurred on the blockchain compared to when it occurred in the physical world.

Hashing is often misunderstood. It is not a form of certification. Hashing only confirms that the bits in a copy are the same as the bits in the source. Other evidence and methods are still needed to establish authenticity beyond matching bits.

Planning a blockchain authentication strategy around 901 and 902

The practical advice that follows from the discussion is to plan the authentication route before trial. Look carefully at FRE 901(b)(9) and understand how it works, and have the witness available who can speak to the process or system. Under FRE 902, a witness may not be needed if the foundation for 902(13) or 902(14) can be laid. If the evidence fits none of these, the general principle of 901 still applies.

Flashcards

12 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.

Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.

1 of 12

Practice quiz

Practice — not graded, not the final exam

Question 1 of 6According to the lesson, why do most companies' evidence pictures combine blockchain data with traditional records?
Choose an answer to check it.

Slides & materials