Authenticating blockchain evidence under FRE 901 and 902
Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.
Up next
Ledger models and dispute types across different digital assetsTranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.
00:00:00Angus, I don't have much to add to this.
00:00:08Nor do I. So the fundamentals for the evidentiary record. So this is an interesting concept, right? Because blockchain and evidentiary terms takes on different definitions based on how it's being used.
00:00:23Right. So and how it's intended to be used. So maybe you want to kick it off, Angus, sort of with the technical discretion and sort of what it means for proof.
00:00:35And then Justin weigh in and then judge you weigh in as well. And I'll follow along with any outstanding comments. But you guys look like you got most of them. So I'll turn it over to you, Angus.
00:00:46Yeah, especially in cases like if just distribute a ledger or a tax or decentralized exchange, there's nobody that's that's running it. Right. It's just a bunch of code that's that's generating the lender itself.
00:01:00It's not a business. Often there's no custodian. Often the business itself, the business to the extent that it really exists in any way, shape or form is like completely decentralized and shoots money money to somebody with a wallet somewhere in like.
00:01:15You know, for example, tether is in Nicaragua. It's outside of the subpoena power of any course. There's just nobody that you can you can bring into authenticate anything.
00:01:26And so trying to prove the authenticity of a blockchain record is often if you run it right into the wrong court or the other side runs the right argument.
00:01:43It becomes potentially impossible under some traditional views of the rules of evidence.
00:01:53Justin. Yeah, I think that the in terms of evidence, right, if you need to introduce the blockchain, typically you're going to need like it's an interesting question, actually, as to whether or not you would need an expert.
00:02:06But you would need it. You would need it probably in the current state of the world. You would want to have an expert. I think everyone that's tried to do that has has used an expert.
00:02:15And I think even though the blockchain is. I mean, the analogy might be right. It's sort of like, OK, it is it is not a in the control of an entity that you can subpoena.
00:02:26But you can bring in an expert witness who can testify as to like what it is and what they're observing about it. Right.
00:02:33That's that's typically how you're going to want to get in evidence about blockchain transactions.
00:02:39Someone analogous to having somebody come in and like talk about a geological feature. Right. There's no one to subpoena to understand like the geological feature you can't control who controls it.
00:02:49But you can bring in an expert who's familiar with geological features can describe it to you and any like testing or work that they might have done.
00:02:57So it is in that right. That is how decentralized blockchain evidence has to be admitted.
00:03:03And I think what we've seen in the early cases is that that's been that's been successful. Courts have treated that as a reasonable way to bring in blockchain evidence.
00:03:13And I think what what I would have to add to this is I think what I find with practitioners and judges is they complete two ideas.
00:03:26And that is the business records here, say exception and authentication. And they are two different concerns.
00:03:34And if we look at most of what blockchain is, it is computer generated information. By definition, computer generated information is not hearsay under the FRE and even under the California evidence code.
00:03:48The cases are uniform. People forget that. And so if we have something that is completely machine generated, like the blockchain, we don't have a hearsay problem.
00:03:59And so we don't need to worry about a custodian of records because we're not trying to establish the business records exception.
00:04:05We're in 901 and 902 area where we need to figure out, can we authenticate this in a way that satisfies the tribunal?
00:04:14And a couple of things that, again, practitioners and I think bench officers sometimes forget the standard for authentication is have you presented sufficient evidence for the trial of fact to conclude that it is what it purports to be.
00:04:31That's it. And so I think that if we start looking at each part of our chain of evidence, and I'm sorry to use that particular term because I think it's going to be confusing.
00:04:43But if we're looking at each particular component of what we're trying to admit and we separate the concerns that we just talked about in the last slide, then a lot of this evidence is going to be authenticated under 901, which doesn't limit the ways that you can authenticate evidence.
00:05:03It's can you convince your trial of fact or can you convince your tribunal that the trial of fact could find sufficient evidence?
00:05:10And I think that that's where we want to concentrate is really being robust in our analysis of what it is that actually applies to this component of the evidence that we're trying to get in.
Automatically generated; it may contain errors.
Study materials
Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.
Study notes
Why decentralized blockchain systems complicate traditional authentication
Angus F. Ni explained that blockchain evidence does not fit neatly into traditional evidentiary frameworks because the technology takes on different meanings depending on how it is used. In cases involving a distributed ledger, a decentralized exchange, or similar systems, there is often no single entity running the system. It is simply code generating a ledger, not a business with a custodian.
Angus F. Ni noted that even where something resembling a business exists, it may be completely decentralized, moving funds to a wallet holder somewhere outside any court's reach. He gave the example that Tether is located in Nicaragua, outside the subpoena power of any court. Because there is often nobody who can be brought in to authenticate the record, proving the authenticity of a blockchain record can become effectively impossible under some traditional views of the rules of evidence, especially if a party ends up in the wrong court or the other side raises the right argument.
Using expert witnesses to authenticate blockchain evidence
Justin Herring addressed how blockchain evidence actually gets introduced. He raised the open question of whether an expert is strictly required, but noted that in the current state of the law, every party that has tried to introduce blockchain evidence has used an expert.
Justin Herring offered an analogy: blockchain evidence is like a geological feature. There is no one to subpoena to "control" a geological feature, but an expert witness familiar with it can testify about what it is, what they observed, and what testing or work they performed. In the same way, a blockchain expert witness can testify about what the blockchain is and what they are observing about it, even though no entity can be subpoenaed to authenticate it directly. Justin Herring stated that this is how decentralized blockchain evidence has to be admitted, and that early cases show courts have treated this approach as a reasonable way to bring in blockchain evidence.
Distinguishing the business records hearsay exception from FRE 901/902 authentication
Hon. Jackson Lucky identified a common confusion among practitioners and judges: conflating the business records hearsay exception with authentication. These are two separate concerns.
Most of what blockchain produces is computer-generated information. By definition, computer-generated information is not hearsay under the Federal Rules of Evidence, and Hon. Jackson Lucky noted the same is true even under the California evidence code, with cases uniformly supporting this point. Because the blockchain record is machine generated, there is no hearsay problem, and therefore no need to establish a custodian of records or satisfy the business records exception. Instead, the real question falls under FRE 901 and 902: can the evidence be authenticated in a way that satisfies the tribunal.
The FRE 901 standard for authenticating blockchain evidence
Hon. Jackson Lucky described the authentication standard as straightforward: has sufficient evidence been presented for the trier of fact to conclude that the item is what it purports to be. That is the entire standard.
Hon. Jackson Lucky recommended breaking the evidence into its separate components rather than treating it as one undifferentiated "chain of evidence," and separating the hearsay concern from the authentication concern for each component. FRE 901 does not limit the ways evidence can be authenticated. The practical question is whether the proponent can convince the tribunal that a reasonable trier of fact could find sufficient evidence of authenticity. Hon. Jackson Lucky suggested that the focus should be on a robust, component-by-component analysis of what actually applies to the specific piece of evidence being offered.
How the speakers' points fit together on blockchain evidence authentication
Daniel B. Garrie opened the discussion by framing blockchain evidence as taking on different definitions depending on how it is used and how it is intended to be used, and invited Angus F. Ni to begin with the technical dimension before Justin Herring and Hon. Jackson Lucky added their perspectives. Taken together, the speakers described a layered approach: recognize that decentralized systems often lack a custodian (Angus F. Ni), use expert testimony to describe what the blockchain record is and how it was observed (Justin Herring), and separate the authentication inquiry under FRE 901/902 from any hearsay analysis, since computer-generated blockchain data is not hearsay (Hon. Jackson Lucky).
Flashcards
13 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.
Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.
1 of 13
Practice quiz
Practice — not graded, not the final exam