Legal Cyber Academy

Where courts and tribunals get blockchain evidence wrong

Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.

Up next

Authenticating blockchain evidence under FRE 901 and 902
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.

00:00:00I agree. Excellent point. So, you know, where are courts and tribunals get it wrong? So I'm going to throw out a couple basic things.

00:00:10They think it's like Amazon OneClick. I think Angus sort of alluded to this and they think, oh, you click a button and you watch where this really cool graph gets made and voila.

00:00:23The truth is, is it's so much more complicated and so many different ways, right? What is the value? What was the exchange? Where did you trade it? Who did you trade it with?

00:00:33What was the counter, you know, counterparty risk on the trade? There's a litany of things that play into this and immutability gets confused often, very often with authenticity.

00:00:46And I can tell you as the arbitrator who hears crypto disputes, I often have to help the litigants understand the difference because there is a difference.

00:00:57And just because it proves it was not altered after it was written, it doesn't say whether it was accurate when it was written.

00:01:07Okay.

00:01:09That is a different concept. I'm sorry, it's a little pet peeve of mine. I didn't need to hijack it. So maybe, Justin, you can sort of walk us through then judge and Angus weigh in as well.

00:01:23Yeah, happy to do that. I think you hit on some of the key issues, right? The one that is fundamental is if the issue is who's responsible, whose crypto is it, who did it, whatever it is, right?

00:01:41Which is sort of the issue in many of the criminal cases and what this evidence is being used to prove. I think that you're right. The key evidentiary point is almost always like the address, right?

00:01:57Even if you have a transparent blockchain, like the Bitcoin blockchain, where the transactions are visible and permanently recorded in immutable fashion, what that means is you have a long string, a long cryptographic string that identifies the addresses and the transactions and the amounts.

00:02:20What you don't have is anything on the blockchain that ties that to actual human beings or even corporations, legal persons. So establishing that is usually the key evidentiary step, right? You need evidence about, and you need evidence.

00:02:35Now, in some cases, in civil cases between parties, they may just agree on who owned it, and this may not be an issue. But when those issues arise, you find yourself in the domain of a lot of traditional attribution evidence.

00:02:47You might use to attribute other kinds of assets. Did they do or say other things in their lives that indicated that they controlled or thought that they controlled this crypto, right? Was the funds tied to them in any way.

00:03:01One of the first times crypto tracing led to a breakthrough in one of my cases. There are unique things you can do with a blockchain. In one of the cases that I worked on as a prosecutor was because of a transaction that touched on the address that the criminals we knew criminals had used.

00:03:16That occurred before the crime even happened, right? And it's a type of tracing that connected back to a transaction that was ultimately connected to a person because it had a clear benefit for them, right?

00:03:30And this type of evidence, attribution evidence, is not necessarily unique to crypto. It might be the same thing you would use. Not that different in kind of nature from the way you might prove that a bank account in a fake name actually belonged to a particular person.

00:03:46That said, and I think we're going to get into this, there's often sort of technical evidence around who may have controlled it that's available, right? Through crypto tracing tools, collect evidence from like a myriad of sources to assign association between addresses, and sometimes link it to information about who or what might actually have control over those assets.

00:04:07But I think converting from an attribution perspective, taking blockchain evidence and making it useful turns on that last step, right? The connection between the addresses and the actual person's people.

00:04:24Judge?

00:04:30Yeah, I think that since we're the target of the slide title where courts of tribunals get it wrong, I'll weigh in. And I think that this is where real lawyering comes in, right? Because if you have a tribunal that is sophisticated and is dealing with these issues and you can basically race through this because you know that the tribunal understands these decisions.

00:04:58That's great. But if you're not in a forum like that and you're walking somebody through this, you know, you're going to have sometimes a tribunal that understands it, but sometimes you're going to have a tribunal that has difficulty distinguishing between something that's machine generated and something that is user generated and machine stored, right?

00:05:23They're going to have that fundamental misunderstanding, you know, and we can look at published decisions from different circuits where, you know, Liz Araga and Oliver, I think, are two examples where you have tribunals reaching different conclusions on what tends to be a tie to a human being or human generated information and machine generated information.

00:05:48So I think you need to put some thought as an advocate when you're when you're going into the tribunal. All right. What's what's the level of understanding that I have? What's the package that I'm putting together?

00:06:00And how am I going to make these distinctions clear to the tribunal that, hey, look, when we are looking at the chain, that is that is an immutable record of an event.

00:06:14It doesn't tell us the envelope. So I always put it like that's right. That's the letter, but we don't have the envelope yet. And and getting your tribunal to understand what's the letter and what's the envelope can be super important.

Automatically generated; it may contain errors.

Study materials

Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.

Study notes

Common misconception that blockchain evidence analysis is push-button simple

Daniel B. Garrie opens by describing a frequent misunderstanding among courts and tribunals: the belief that blockchain evidence works like "Amazon OneClick," where a button is clicked and a graph instantly appears. In reality, the analysis is far more complex. Questions that must be answered include:

  • What is the value of the asset?
  • What was the exchange?
  • Where did the trade occur?
  • Who was the counterparty, and what was the counterparty risk?

There is no single automated process that resolves all of these questions at once.

Difference between immutability and authenticity in blockchain evidence

Daniel B. Garrie identifies a recurring source of confusion: treating immutability and authenticity as the same concept. They are not.

  • Immutability means a record was not altered after it was written.
  • Authenticity concerns whether the record was accurate when it was written.

A blockchain entry can be immutable and still inaccurate at the moment of creation. Garrie notes he often has to explain this distinction to litigants directly.

Why attribution evidence connects blockchain addresses to real people

Justin Herring identifies attribution as the fundamental evidentiary issue in many cases, especially criminal matters: who is responsible, whose crypto is it, who did it.

  • Even on a transparent, permanently recorded blockchain such as the Bitcoin blockchain, what exists is a long cryptographic string identifying addresses, transactions, and amounts.
  • Nothing on the blockchain itself ties that string to an actual human being or legal person (such as a corporation).
  • In civil cases, parties may simply agree on ownership, removing the issue entirely. When they do not agree, the case moves into the domain of traditional attribution evidence.

How crypto tracing tools and traditional evidence establish attribution

Justin Herring explains that attribution evidence is not unique to crypto in kind. It resembles proving that a bank account opened under a fake name actually belongs to a specific person. Relevant evidence includes whether a person did or said other things in their life indicating they controlled, or believed they controlled, the crypto in question.

Herring describes a case where crypto tracing led to a breakthrough: a transaction touched an address known to be used by criminals, and that transaction occurred before the crime took place. This type of tracing connected back to a transaction that was ultimately tied to a person because it had a clear benefit for them.

Beyond this kind of tracing, crypto tracing tools collect evidence from many sources to assign associations between addresses, and sometimes link those addresses to information about who or what actually controls the assets. Herring states that converting blockchain evidence into something useful turns on that final step: connecting the addresses to actual people.

Why tribunals struggle to distinguish machine-generated from user-generated data

Hon. Jackson Lucky addresses the lesson's framing directly, noting that this is where "real lawyering" matters. A sophisticated tribunal already familiar with these issues allows counsel to move quickly. A less sophisticated tribunal may have a fundamental misunderstanding, particularly difficulty distinguishing between:

  • Information that is machine generated, and
  • Information that is user generated but machine stored.

Jackson Lucky notes that published decisions from different circuits have reached different conclusions on what counts as a tie to a human being versus purely machine-generated information. Advocates need to assess the tribunal's level of understanding and tailor the evidentiary package accordingly.

The letter-and-envelope metaphor for presenting blockchain evidence to tribunals

Hon. Jackson Lucky offers a metaphor for explaining blockchain evidence to a tribunal: the blockchain itself is an immutable record of an event, comparable to a letter, but it does not provide the envelope, meaning the context of who sent it, to whom, and under what circumstances. Getting a tribunal to understand the difference between the "letter" (the immutable record) and the "envelope" (the attribution and context around it) can be critical to a case.

Flashcards

13 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.

Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.

1 of 13

Practice quiz

Practice — not graded, not the final exam

Question 1 of 5What does Daniel B. Garrie identify as a common misconception courts and tribunals have about blockchain evidence?
Choose an answer to check it.

Slides & materials