Legal Cyber Academy

Panelist introductions: Judges, arbitrators, and attorneys specializing in crypto disputes

Free. Watch without an account. Sign in to save progress and take the exam.

Up next

Why digital asset disputes are becoming a routine part of litigation
TranscriptThe player shows YouTube’s automatic captions, which are machine captions we do not review. The full transcript is below.

00:00:02Today's speakers are Daniel B. Garrie, Founder of Law and Forensics, Neutral at JAMSS, Adjunct Faculty at Harvard, Hon. Judge Jackson Lucky, Mediator, Arbitrator, and Neutral at JAMSS, Justin Herring, Partner at Mayor Brown, and Angus F. Ni. Partner at Morrow-Ni, LLP. The program materials can be found under the Supplements tab. Thank you for joining us and I will now turn things over to you.

00:00:32I will now turn it over to today's moderator, Daniel Garrie, for further introductions and to start the program.

00:01:02This presentation is offered for educational informational uses only. With that said, we have our fantastic photos here. I'll introduce myself quickly and then I'll let Judge Lucky introduce himself and Council Herring and Council Ni introduce themselves.

00:01:21My relevant background, I've been working in crypto fintech, teaching at Harvard elsewhere on this very topic. I'm an Arbitrator expert in blockchain-based disputes testifying in multiple trials, as well as serving as independent board members, so on and so forth.

00:01:40With all that said, I'm going to turn it over to my much more accomplished and educated panelists. Judge Lucky, you're up.

00:01:47All right, I'm Jack Lucky. I am a retired judge, now a Neutral at JAMSS, doing arbitration, mediation, and private judging. I was on the bench as a state court judge in California, Riverside County, for 13 years during that time.

00:02:05I taught quite a bit on electronic evidence and the admissibility of electronic evidence to judges and continue to do so for lawyers and judges.

00:02:15And I'll turn it over to, I think, we said, Justin's next.

00:02:22Yes, sir. Justin, you're on mute, but we're sure I can tell him how great you are.

00:02:31All right, let me take a shot at that, then. Well, I appreciate the offer, Daniel. Justin, I'm Justin Herring and I'm a partner in the New York Office of Mayor Brown.

00:02:44I've been here for three years and before this, I was in the government for 13 years.

00:02:48I served as the head of the cybersecurity division at the New York Department of Financial Services and relevant to sort of today's discussion.

00:02:56In addition to cybersecurity issues, worked on a number of the crypto and blockchain regulatory issues at DFS, which, as you may know, was involved in this space as the originator of the bit license for crypto companies.

00:03:10Before that, I was a federal prosecutor for nine years and I served as the first chief of the cyber crimes unit in the U.S. Attorney's Office in the District of New Jersey.

00:03:20In that, relevant to today's discussion, I was one of the first users of crypto tracing in law enforcement.

00:03:28I think it's possible that no one kept a record that I may have had the first seizure of crypto in a criminal prosecution case back in 2012.

00:03:38I have followed these issues with interest ever since and have also, in my current role, represented clients in disputes that involved crypto or crypto ownership issues.

00:03:54Hi, everyone. I'm Angus Nee. I'm a partner at Moroni LLP. We're a small commercial litigation boutique of 10 people.

00:04:02We represent many crypto and crypto adjacent individuals and companies.

00:04:09We've represented cryptocurrency exchanges. We represent individuals who have had their accounts hacked.

00:04:17We have chased hackers. We have frozen crypto. We represented cryptocurrency wallet builders and cryptocurrency issuers.

Automatically generated; it may contain errors.

Study materials

Notes, flashcards and practice questions for this lesson, reviewed before publication.

Study notes

Digital asset evidence from investigation to courtroom

This opening lesson introduces the panel and, through the introductions, maps the ground the course covers: how evidence about digital assets is generated, traced, regulated and proved, in criminal and civil matters alike. The speakers are Daniel B. Garrie, Hon. Jackson Lucky, Justin Herring and Angus F. Ni.

Admissibility of electronic evidence as the starting point

One thread named at the outset is the admissibility of electronic evidence: what a proponent must show before a court or tribunal will accept a digital record. Blockchain records are a form of electronic evidence, so the general questions of authentication and admissibility apply to them too. Later lessons take up how the Federal Rules of Evidence handle blockchain records specifically, and where courts and tribunals get them wrong.

Crypto tracing in criminal investigations and seizures

Crypto tracing is described as a tool that has been used in law enforcement, including in criminal prosecutions involving the seizure of crypto. Tracing follows the movement of value across a blockchain to identify where assets came from and where they went. Whether tracing can tie an address to an actual person is a question the course returns to repeatedly.

Regulation of crypto companies and the New York BitLicense

Regulators are also part of the digital asset evidence picture. New York's Department of Financial Services was involved in this space as the originator of the BitLicense for crypto companies, and its crypto and blockchain regulatory work sat alongside cybersecurity issues.

Civil disputes that put digital assets into litigation

On the civil side, the lesson lists the kinds of matters that bring digital assets before a court or tribunal:

  • disputes over crypto ownership;
  • disputes involving cryptocurrency exchanges;
  • individuals whose accounts were hacked, and efforts to chase the hackers;
  • freezing crypto in the course of a dispute;
  • matters involving cryptocurrency wallet builders and cryptocurrency issuers.

These disputes are heard in more than one kind of forum: courts, and also arbitration, mediation and private judging.

Why these settings matter for proving digital asset evidence

Taken together, these threads frame the course's central problem. A single digital asset dispute can touch a criminal investigation, a regulatory regime and a civil claim, and each of those settings depends on evidence that can be preserved, traced and authenticated. The lessons that follow move from why these disputes have become routine, to the evidentiary fundamentals, to tracing and attribution, to discovery and arbitration strategy.

Flashcards

8 cards. Test your recall, then flip to check.

Select the card, or press Space, to flip it. Left and right arrow keys move between cards.

1 of 8

Practice quiz

Practice — not graded, not the final exam

Question 1 of 4Which agency originated the BitLicense for crypto companies, as described in this lesson?
Choose an answer to check it.

Slides & materials